EMCA Seminar: 2020 - TOP
regular Time of ONLINE MEETING : wednesdays (except the 4th wednesday) 12:30-16:00
instructor: SHIRO KASHIMURA (PROFESSOR EMERITUS, KOBE UNIVERSITY)
Theme: From Parsons to Garfinkel
-> Instructions for online participation (in Japanese)
-> Announcement of LINE WORKS CORP: On the media reportage of security concerns in LINE service.
-> EMCA seminar video clips
GENERAL INSTRUCTION
Posted 2020/04/15
The EMCA (Ethnomethodology and Conversation Analysis) Seminar of 2020 continues discussions on Garfinkel's Parsons Primer and thematically related papers.
Parsons Primer is now edited and published by professors Anne W. Rawls and Jason Turowetz, The Book's page, along with introduction by Rawls and Turowetz, and related materials of the book including a new chapter based on the talk on 1961, "The Program of Ethnomethodology," by Garfinkel.
Topics of 2020 Seminar:
[6] Garfinkel's reading of Parsons on "Structured Strain" - Chapter for Ad Hoc Parsons Partial Draft for Illustrative Use of "Structured Strain":
[7] Garfinkel's reading of Parsons on "Values"-- Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT AND NOTE FOR A CHAPTER ON VALUES,,PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USES p.1 - p.128
Additional Information:
(1) The schedule and its changes will be announced on this page.
(2) The course materials are to be distributed through this site. Password will be required to see some materials due to copyright consideration.
(3) On-line internet participation to the seminar is provided through Zoom and Line Works. -> Details (in Japanese).
(4) The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my sites: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology, and Ethnomethodology after 1970 - Suggestions and Informations to be added to these sites are welcomed.
(5) The Chronological List of Parsons's works is here.
Anyone who is interested is welcome to attend. Please contact via Facebook.
-> Announcement of LINE WORKS CORP: On the media reportage of security concerns in LINE service.
-> EMCA seminar video clips
GENERAL INSTRUCTION
Posted 2020/04/15
The EMCA (Ethnomethodology and Conversation Analysis) Seminar of 2020 continues discussions on Garfinkel's Parsons Primer and thematically related papers.
Parsons Primer is now edited and published by professors Anne W. Rawls and Jason Turowetz, The Book's page, along with introduction by Rawls and Turowetz, and related materials of the book including a new chapter based on the talk on 1961, "The Program of Ethnomethodology," by Garfinkel.
Topics of 2020 Seminar:
[6] Garfinkel's reading of Parsons on "Structured Strain" - Chapter for Ad Hoc Parsons Partial Draft for Illustrative Use of "Structured Strain":
[7] Garfinkel's reading of Parsons on "Values"-- Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT AND NOTE FOR A CHAPTER ON VALUES,,PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USES p.1 - p.128
Additional Information:
(1) The schedule and its changes will be announced on this page.
(2) The course materials are to be distributed through this site. Password will be required to see some materials due to copyright consideration.
(3) On-line internet participation to the seminar is provided through Zoom and Line Works. -> Details (in Japanese).
(4) The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my sites: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology, and Ethnomethodology after 1970 - Suggestions and Informations to be added to these sites are welcomed.
(5) The Chronological List of Parsons's works is here.
Anyone who is interested is welcome to attend. Please contact via Facebook.
[7] Garfinkel's reading of Parsons on "Values"-- Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT AND NOTE FOR A CHAPTER ON VALUES,,PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USES p.1 - p.128
= Rawls ed. (2019): pp.203-270.
[この章の目次]
価値についての章のためのタイトル付きノートのリスト
p.1 I. 「意味の計算(Calculus of significance)」としての秩序の問題の課題のParsons の説明(Parsons' delineation of the Tasks of the Problem of Order as a "Calculus of Significance")
p.1 II . 「集団」という概念の諸困難をParsons による「社会システム」の用法が取り扱う方法(How Parsons' usage of "social sytem" handles difficultires with the concept, "group")
p.6 III. 観察可能物を把握するための、諸対象の図式の行為-状況に先立つ諸決定(Decisions that preceeded the action-situation of objects schema to conceive observables)
p.11 IV. 社会的相互行為のパラダイム(Paradigm of social interaction)
p.17 V. 規範と規範的(Norms and normative)
p.24 VI. 規範的環境、(E); 諸規範と諸価値(Normative environment, (E): norms and values)
p.38 VII 諸ルールと行動の基準(Rules and maixms of conduct)
p.40 VIII 諸価値(values)
p.53 IX ゲームの基礎的諸ルールの使用によって説明された諸価値(Values explicated with the use of basic rules of game)
p.68 X 価値の安定性といくつかの批判への解答(Value stability and an answer to some criticisms)
p.71 XI 諸価値対諸標語(values versus slogans)
p.73 XII 諸価値は行為から推測されない(Values are not inferred from actions)
p.74 XIII 諸価値は規範を制御する(Values control norms)
p.75 XIV 諸価値への確約の「諸水準」("Level" of commitment to values)
p.77 XV 諸価値は「頭の中に」は存在しない(Values are not "in the head")
p.79 XVI 諸価値と主観的諸カテゴリー(Values and the subjective categories)
p.80 XVII 現実と知覚された社会諸構造(Real perceived social structures)
p.83 XVIII 諸価値という用語によって意図される経験的観察可能物(Empirical observables intended by the term, values)
p.86 XIX 諸価値の経験的意味(Empirical meaning of values)
p.87 XX
p.88 XXI 諸目標(Goals)
p.89 XXII 諸価値は諸規範にそれらの「正当性の根拠」を与える;諸規範は諸価値にそれらの産出のためのプログラムを与える(Values furnish norms their "rationale of legitimacy"; norms furnish values the programs for their production)
p.93 XXIII 二つの定理(The two theorems)
p.94 XXIV 「社会的価値システム」における、諸批判へのParsons の応答の評価(Review of Parsons' answers to critics in "The Societal Value System")
p.98 XXV アメリカの諸価値についてのParsons とかれの批判者の議論を決定するための方法の一根拠(A rationale for a method for deciding between Parsons' and his critics' arguments on American values)
p.112 XXVI 方法についての追加議論(More on a method)
p.125 XXVII 諸価値の可能な評価陳述(A possible review statement of values)
[Links] (password required)
[Links]
- Photocopied Texts
-Typed Texts
- Japanese Translation (第I〜V章)(2020.9.3)
- Notes on Garfinkel "The Program of Ethnomethodology"(1961)
[Garfionkel's and Parsons' Writings]
-Parsons, "Culture and Social System Revisited" (1972) Social Science Quarterly, Vol.53, No. 2, 253-266.
-Parsons, "A Tentative Outline of American Values" (1989/1959 or 1960) (Lidz 1989: p.571.)Theory, Culture and Society, Vol.6: 577-612..
-Lidz 1989 "The American Value System: A Commentary on Talcott Parsons's Perspective and Understanding." Theory, Culture and Society, Vol.6: 559-576.
-Parsons, Talcott Theories of Society I , II (1961)
-Parsons, T. & W. White Values of American Society: Manuscripts from the American Society Project I. (Edited by Victor Lidz & Helmut Staubmann) (LIT: 2016/1960)
-Parsons, T. & Bales, R. F. Family: Socialization and Interaction Process. (Routledge, 1956)
-Parsons, Talcott Politics and Social Structure. (1969) <- "Commitments", "Boundary exchange"
-Parsons Actor Situation and Normative Pattern (1939/2010)
-Parsons Social Structure and Personality. (1964)
-Parsons Structure and Process in Modern Societies (1960)
-Parsons "The Role of Ideas in Social Action"American Sociological Review, 3(5): 652-664 (Oct., 1938)
-Parsons "An Approach to the Sociology of Knowledge" (1959) <-"Knowledge", "Value", "Norm"
-Garfinkel "Aspects of the Problem of Common-Sense Knowledge of Social Structures" (1959)
1959 Discussion
-Erving Goffman Archive <-Saul Mendlovitz
-Giuseppe Sciortino 2004 "The Societal Community: Conceptual Foundations of a Key Action Theory Concept." CDAMS Discussion paper 04/19E
-Garfinkel 1963 「安定した協調的行為の条件としての『信頼』の概念と実験」(樫村抄訳)(2018.1.22)
[この章の目次]
価値についての章のためのタイトル付きノートのリスト
p.1 I. 「意味の計算(Calculus of significance)」としての秩序の問題の課題のParsons の説明(Parsons' delineation of the Tasks of the Problem of Order as a "Calculus of Significance")
p.1 II . 「集団」という概念の諸困難をParsons による「社会システム」の用法が取り扱う方法(How Parsons' usage of "social sytem" handles difficultires with the concept, "group")
p.6 III. 観察可能物を把握するための、諸対象の図式の行為-状況に先立つ諸決定(Decisions that preceeded the action-situation of objects schema to conceive observables)
p.11 IV. 社会的相互行為のパラダイム(Paradigm of social interaction)
p.17 V. 規範と規範的(Norms and normative)
p.24 VI. 規範的環境、(E); 諸規範と諸価値(Normative environment, (E): norms and values)
p.38 VII 諸ルールと行動の基準(Rules and maixms of conduct)
p.40 VIII 諸価値(values)
p.53 IX ゲームの基礎的諸ルールの使用によって説明された諸価値(Values explicated with the use of basic rules of game)
p.68 X 価値の安定性といくつかの批判への解答(Value stability and an answer to some criticisms)
p.71 XI 諸価値対諸標語(values versus slogans)
p.73 XII 諸価値は行為から推測されない(Values are not inferred from actions)
p.74 XIII 諸価値は規範を制御する(Values control norms)
p.75 XIV 諸価値への確約の「諸水準」("Level" of commitment to values)
p.77 XV 諸価値は「頭の中に」は存在しない(Values are not "in the head")
p.79 XVI 諸価値と主観的諸カテゴリー(Values and the subjective categories)
p.80 XVII 現実と知覚された社会諸構造(Real perceived social structures)
p.83 XVIII 諸価値という用語によって意図される経験的観察可能物(Empirical observables intended by the term, values)
p.86 XIX 諸価値の経験的意味(Empirical meaning of values)
p.87 XX
p.88 XXI 諸目標(Goals)
p.89 XXII 諸価値は諸規範にそれらの「正当性の根拠」を与える;諸規範は諸価値にそれらの産出のためのプログラムを与える(Values furnish norms their "rationale of legitimacy"; norms furnish values the programs for their production)
p.93 XXIII 二つの定理(The two theorems)
p.94 XXIV 「社会的価値システム」における、諸批判へのParsons の応答の評価(Review of Parsons' answers to critics in "The Societal Value System")
p.98 XXV アメリカの諸価値についてのParsons とかれの批判者の議論を決定するための方法の一根拠(A rationale for a method for deciding between Parsons' and his critics' arguments on American values)
p.112 XXVI 方法についての追加議論(More on a method)
p.125 XXVII 諸価値の可能な評価陳述(A possible review statement of values)
[Links] (password required)
[Links]
- Photocopied Texts
-Typed Texts
- Japanese Translation (第I〜V章)(2020.9.3)
- Notes on Garfinkel "The Program of Ethnomethodology"(1961)
[Garfionkel's and Parsons' Writings]
-Parsons, "Culture and Social System Revisited" (1972) Social Science Quarterly, Vol.53, No. 2, 253-266.
-Parsons, "A Tentative Outline of American Values" (1989/1959 or 1960) (Lidz 1989: p.571.)Theory, Culture and Society, Vol.6: 577-612..
-Lidz 1989 "The American Value System: A Commentary on Talcott Parsons's Perspective and Understanding." Theory, Culture and Society, Vol.6: 559-576.
-Parsons, Talcott Theories of Society I , II (1961)
-Parsons, T. & W. White Values of American Society: Manuscripts from the American Society Project I. (Edited by Victor Lidz & Helmut Staubmann) (LIT: 2016/1960)
-Parsons, T. & Bales, R. F. Family: Socialization and Interaction Process. (Routledge, 1956)
-Parsons, Talcott Politics and Social Structure. (1969) <- "Commitments", "Boundary exchange"
-Parsons Actor Situation and Normative Pattern (1939/2010)
-Parsons Social Structure and Personality. (1964)
-Parsons Structure and Process in Modern Societies (1960)
-Parsons "The Role of Ideas in Social Action"American Sociological Review, 3(5): 652-664 (Oct., 1938)
-Parsons "An Approach to the Sociology of Knowledge" (1959) <-"Knowledge", "Value", "Norm"
-Garfinkel "Aspects of the Problem of Common-Sense Knowledge of Social Structures" (1959)
1959 Discussion
-Erving Goffman Archive <-Saul Mendlovitz
-Giuseppe Sciortino 2004 "The Societal Community: Conceptual Foundations of a Key Action Theory Concept." CDAMS Discussion paper 04/19E
-Garfinkel 1963 「安定した協調的行為の条件としての『信頼』の概念と実験」(樫村抄訳)(2018.1.22)
[6] Garfinkel's reading of Parsons on "Structured Strain" - Chapter for Ad Hoc Parsons Partial Draft for Illustrative Use of "Structured Strain"
[Links]
- Typed texts
- Photocopied texts
- Japanese translation
- Notes on the materials
- Rawls ed. 2019 Garfinkel Parsons Primer. (Springer)
- Contents of PP in Rawls edition
[Instruction Movie Clips]
2020.05.28~ 6.8 Parsons' Papers on American Kinship System 4 Parts:
Part1, PartII, Part III-1, Part III-2, Part IV-1a, Part IV-1b, Part IV-2a, Part-IV-1b
2020.05.01 "Social Structure without "the Social-as-Beyond-the-Individual"
2020.04.19 "'Reflecting' Reality on the Social Structure: Parsons and Garfinkel Compared on Parsons's Analysis of Family,"
Part I, Part II, Part III.
2020.04.16 "Reading Parsons's The Kinship System article (Parsons 1943) by Garfinkel: Introduction
2020.04.15 "Reading the Kinship Diagram in Parsons (1943)"
2020.04.14 "Explaining Parsons Primer: Strain"
[Parsons' papers related to the chapter]
- 1942a Age and Sex in the Social Structure of the United States.(>Essays, revised edition, chapter V) [-> Partial Draft ... "Structured Strain": A Chapter in Parsons Primer.]
- 1943 The Kinship System of the Contemporary United States.(>Essays, revised edition, chapter IX)[<- Davis, K. 1936, 1937, 1937(w. Warner), 1940a, 1940b][1955?-> Partial Draft ... "Structured Strain": A Chapter in Parsons Primer.]
- 1947 Certain Primary Sources and Patterns of Aggression in the Social Structure of the Western World. Psychiatry. (=Essays, revised edition, chapter XIV) (?-> Partial Draft ... "Structured Strain": A Chapter in Parsons Primer)
[Other related works]
- Parsons 1943 <- 1940a Davis, K. "The Sociology of Parent-Youth Conflict,"
1940b Davis, K. "The Child and the Social Structure,"
1937 Davis, K. & W. L. Warner "Structural Analysis of Kinship,"
1937 Davis, K. "The Sociology of Prostitution,"
1936 Davis. K. (1908 -1997) "Jealousy and Sexual Property,"
- Parsons 1951 The Social System
-Parsons & Shils 1951 Toward a General Theory of Action. Ebook.
- Linton, Ralph 1936 The Study of Man
[Parsons and Garfinkel's Life Events]
[Links]
- Typed texts
- Photocopied texts
- Japanese translation
- Notes on the materials
- Rawls ed. 2019 Garfinkel Parsons Primer. (Springer)
- Contents of PP in Rawls edition
[Instruction Movie Clips]
2020.05.28~ 6.8 Parsons' Papers on American Kinship System 4 Parts:
Part1, PartII, Part III-1, Part III-2, Part IV-1a, Part IV-1b, Part IV-2a, Part-IV-1b
2020.05.01 "Social Structure without "the Social-as-Beyond-the-Individual"
2020.04.19 "'Reflecting' Reality on the Social Structure: Parsons and Garfinkel Compared on Parsons's Analysis of Family,"
Part I, Part II, Part III.
2020.04.16 "Reading Parsons's The Kinship System article (Parsons 1943) by Garfinkel: Introduction
2020.04.15 "Reading the Kinship Diagram in Parsons (1943)"
2020.04.14 "Explaining Parsons Primer: Strain"
[Parsons' papers related to the chapter]
- 1942a Age and Sex in the Social Structure of the United States.(>Essays, revised edition, chapter V) [-> Partial Draft ... "Structured Strain": A Chapter in Parsons Primer.]
- 1943 The Kinship System of the Contemporary United States.(>Essays, revised edition, chapter IX)[<- Davis, K. 1936, 1937, 1937(w. Warner), 1940a, 1940b][1955?-> Partial Draft ... "Structured Strain": A Chapter in Parsons Primer.]
- 1947 Certain Primary Sources and Patterns of Aggression in the Social Structure of the Western World. Psychiatry. (=Essays, revised edition, chapter XIV) (?-> Partial Draft ... "Structured Strain": A Chapter in Parsons Primer)
[Other related works]
- Parsons 1943 <- 1940a Davis, K. "The Sociology of Parent-Youth Conflict,"
1940b Davis, K. "The Child and the Social Structure,"
1937 Davis, K. & W. L. Warner "Structural Analysis of Kinship,"
1937 Davis, K. "The Sociology of Prostitution,"
1936 Davis. K. (1908 -1997) "Jealousy and Sexual Property,"
- Parsons 1951 The Social System
-Parsons & Shils 1951 Toward a General Theory of Action. Ebook.
- Linton, Ralph 1936 The Study of Man
[Parsons and Garfinkel's Life Events]
- 1937 The Structure of Social Action. McGraw-Hill.
- “Since 1937, Parsons has dealt with the theory of social action systematically, rather than historically. His efforts in this direction have been presented in courses at Harvard University and in a still-unpublished manuscript. Also since 1937, Parsons has come to be increasingly interested in … Freud and the diverse trends stemming from him.” (Barber 1949: 351.)[=Referring presumably to Parsons 2010(1939)]Edward H. Hartshorne, Robert Bierstedt, Kingsley Davis, George Devereux, Robert Merton, participated in a discussion group, under Parsons’ guidance,which occupied itself with influence, authority & propaganda in Nazi Germany. (Gerhardt 2002: 65-6.)
- Family kinship system & women are of his interest as to liberation from authoritarianism of Germany. (1943-45).(ibid.)
- 1939b (published in 2010 as V.Lidz & H. Staubmann eds. 2010) Actor, Situation and Normative Pattern: An Essay in the Theory of Social Action. [The manuscript was probably used as teaching material from 1940 until 1951 when it was supplanted by the drafts of Parsons 1951a & 1951b (Lidz, 2010 “Preface”, p. 2.]
- 1939 [Garfinkel] University of North Carolina (M.A. in Sociology) Master's Thesis: "Inter- and Intra- Homicides in Ten Courts in North Carolina, 1930 - 1940"
- 1940 Znaniecki,F., The Social Role of the Man of Knowledge, Columbia University Press.
- 1940 "Methodological Consequences of the Sociology of Knowledge, " American Journal of Sociology, 46: 330.
- October 1940 - April 1941 Parsons & Schutz exchanged letters [Sprondel ed., 1977(German), 1978(English)]
- 1945a The Present Position and Prospects of Systematic Theory in Sociology. (>Essays, revised edition, chapter XI)
- 1945 Merton, R.K. Sociological Theory, American Journal of Sociology [Referring Lazarsfeld & Merton, formal deduction & Codification (induction) , as sociological theories' essense were emphasized. Merton was an eminent student of Parsons in mid 30's.]
- 1946 Department of Social Relations at Harvard University was established (Johnson & Johnson 1986:131.)
- 1946-1951 Harold Garfinkel came to, and stayed at Harvard University, Department of Social Relations (Ph.D. in Sociology, June, 1952: Dissertation: The Perception of the Other: A Study in Social Order. [Dissertation Committee: Talcott Parsons, Frederick Mosteller, Robert F. Bales, See also, Garfinkel 2002:83-84.]
- January 1949a Essays in Sociological Theory Pure and Applied. 1st edition. The Free Press. [The list of articles (the year of publication) Part 1 Sociological Theory and Its Historical Roots; I. The Position of Sociological Theory (1948) ; II The Present Position and Prospects of Systematic Theory in Sociology (1945) ; III A Selection from “Toward a Common Language for the Area of Social Science; VI The Theoretical Development of the Sociology of Religion; V Max Weber [Introduction of Parsons translated/edited. 1947); Part II Essays in the Application of Sociological Theory; VI The Role of Ideas in Social Action; VII An Analytical Approach to the Theory of Social Stratification (1940) VIII The Professions and Social Structure (1939); IX The Motivation of Economic Activities (1940) ; X Age and Sex in the Social Structure of the United States (1942); XI The Kinship System of the Contemporary United States (1943); XII Certain Primary Sources and Patterns of Aggression in the Social Structure of the Western World (1947);XIII Propaganda and Social Control (1942) ; XIV The Problem of Controlled Institutional Change (1945); Part III A Biographical Sketch of Talcott Parsons by Bernard Barber; Bibliography of Talcott Parsons]
- ((Chapter I “The Position of Sociological Theory, Chapter III “A Selection from ‘Toward A Common Language for the Area of Social Science,” Chapter V “Max Weber” (=“Introduction” by Parsons to Weber Theory of Social and Economic Organization, 1947), are omitted in Essays 1954 revised edition because of addition of Chapters XVIII and XIX.(“This [omission in the revised edition] is largely because the classification set forth there is now completely obsolete, in the light of the much more elaborate attempt at classification of institutional patterns developed in Chapters III and IV of The Social System. The main interest of the early version is as a first stage of the scheme which has been much more fully developed in this later publication.” Parsons 1954:12( “introduction”)) ((Chapters of Revised edition, though the articles are published before 1949, but are not included in the original edition are: VI. Democracy and Social Structure in Pre-Nazi Germany (1942); VII. Some Sociological Aspects of the Fascist Movements (1942) ; X. The Theoretical Development of the Sociology of Religion (1944) ; XIII. Population and the Social Structure of Japan ( 1946 ) . Chapters of Revised edition that are published after 1949 and are oncluded in the Revised edition are: XV. Social Classes and Class Conflict in the Light of Recent Sociological Theory (1949); XVI. Psychoanalysis and the Social Structure (1950) ; XVII. The Prospects of Sociological Theory (1950) ; XVIII. A Sociologist Looks at the Legal Profession ( 1952 ) ; XIX. A Revised Analytical Approach to the Theory of Social Stratification (1953) ]
- 1949b Social Classes and Class Conflict in the Light of Recent Sociological Theory.(Essays, revised edition, chapter XV)
- March 1949c The Structure of Social Action. 2nd edition. The Free Press
For more details, visit my sites:
The Works of Talcott Parsons and Related Events.
The Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology: 1878-1967
The Works of Talcott Parsons and Related Events.
The Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology: 1878-1967
Visit the blog (in Japanese) for additions, comments and other modifications.