2017
EMCA Seminar: Fall of 2017 - Winter of 2018
Time: Tuesdays, 13:20-16:40
Place: Room304, 3rd Floor, "the Frontier" Building, Rokkodai-Campus, Kobe University
Shiro Kashimura
Professor, School of Law
Kobe University
Theme: Garfinkel and Sacks as Collaborators
The EMCA Seminar in Fall of 2017 and Winter of 2018 continues the interests of Spring-Summer of 2017 with additional focus on the collaboration of Garfinkel and Sacks in 1960's. They met during Garfinkel's stay at Harvard from 1959-60, and presumably their collaboration started in 1959. We already saw that Sacks's work and his insights began to be mentioned from the very early materials of Garfinkel's Ethnomethodology Seminars at UCLA (their transcripts are available since February, 1962). We shall continue to look at the papers from the roundtable session on "Reasonable Accounts" by Garfinkel, Sacks, Bittner & Rose at the 16th World Affairs Conference, University of Colorado, 1963, where in some papers delivered by Sacks his experience with law, children, and classical studies of logic, his ways of reading conversational materials were mentioned. In addition, the planned materials for our seminar include Sacks's published works:some of the Sacks's Lectures on Conversation (the transcripts in this book start in 1964 at UCLA) , and some early papers and corresponding lectures by Sacks.
Part I. Introduction to the Problems
[1] September 19 Introduction: the perspective on gloss/reasonable account, activity, the law and other subjects
- 樫村 1992 「法律的探求の社会組織」
Part II. Roundtable on "Reasonable Accounts": transcripts of the talks delivered at Sixteenth Annual Conference on World Affairs, University of Colorado, April 11 and 12, 1963.
[2] October 3 Harold Garfinkel "Mocking Up the Rules of Everyday Activities"
October 24 Reviewing Garfinkel's Mocking Up paper & Comparing it with "Trust" paper
[3] Harvey Sacks "More on Mock-Ups"
- 樫村「1960年代のGarfinkelと『エスノメソドロジー研究』」日本社会学会第90回大会テーマセッション(6) 「エスノメソドロジーと会話分析の半世紀(1)」(2017年11月4日・東京大学) ー> LINK
[4] Harold Garfinkel "Reasonable Accounts"
[5] Egon Bittner "Ethical Symbols"
[6] Edward Rose, Harvey Sacks, Egon Bittner, and Harold Garfinkel "Translations"
Part III The EM-Perspective on Social Structure
[7] Garfinkel 1960 Chapter IV "ADEQUATE' DESCRIPTIONS OF SOCIAL STRUCTURES,PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USESp.79 - p.120.
[8] Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT FOR ILLUSTRATIVE USE OF "STRUCTURED STRAIN",PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USES, p.1 - p.41
[9] Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT AND NOTE FOR A CHAPTER ON VALUES,,PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USES p.1 - p.128
Part IV Harvey Sacks as the Collaborator
[10] Sacks 1999, Harvey "Max Weber's Ancient Judaism" Theory, Culture & Society 16:31. -> LINK
[11] Schegloff 1999, Sacks on Weber and Ancient Judaism
[12] Sacks 1984, Notes on Methodology
[13] Sacks 1968, Search for Help
Additional Information:
(1) The change of schedule will be announced on this page.
(2) The class schedule may be changed considering the seminar participants' needs to present their own research to the class or by other contingencies; then the classes will move down accordingly.
(3) On-line internet participation to the seminar will be possible via Skype or FaceTime depending on the Kobe University's network (KHAN)'s capacity. Please let me know about the expected on-line participation in advance for necessary arrangements.
(4) The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my sites: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology, and Ethnomethodology after 1970 - Suggestions and Informations to be added to these sites are welcomed.
(5) Changes and additions in this site will be announced on twitter and Facebook.
Materials:(Password Required)
-> 2017-18 Seminar Materials
-> 2017 Spring-Summer Materials
-> 2016-17 Fall-WInter Seminar Materials
Additional Information:
MAP -> LINK to Kobe University Access Map (The "frontier" building is the building, No 29.)
While this is a credited course for the graduate students of legal sociology of Kobe University, anyone who is interested is welcome to attend (without credits).
2017
EMCA Seminar: Spring-Summer of 2017
Time: 15:10-17:00,Tuesdays
Place: Room 303, 3rd Floor, "the Frontier" Building, Rokkodai-Campus, Kobe University
Shiro Kashimura
Professor, School of Law
Kobe University
Theme: Ethnomethodology outside the Studies in 1960's
The EMCA Seminar in Spring/Summer of 2017 continues the 2016 seminar and further examines Harold Garfinkel's unpublished works in 1960's. They were not included in the Studies in Ethnomethodology (Garfinkel 1967) possibly or apparently for some reasons. The materials include: a collaborated paper by Garfinkel and Harvey Sacks, "On 'Setting' in Conversation"delivered at ASA San Francisco Annual Meeting, Section on Sociolinguistics, on August 31, 1967: the papers from the roundtable session on "Reasonable Accounts" by Garfinkel, Sacks, Egon Bittner & Edward Rose at the 16th World Affairs Conference, University of Colorado, 1963: and Parsons' Primer (1960-63) .
Part I. On "Setting" in Conversation
"On 'Setting' in Conversation" (Garfinkel & Sacks, 1967) is a paper read at the Sociolinguistic Section of ASA San Francisco Annual Meeting and is mentioned in "Formal Structures of Practical Actions" (Garfinkel & Sacks, 1969, 1986) as its early version. The content of the paper in large part overlaps with the "Formal Structures" paper but differs in that it focuses on the issue of repairing the indexicals more clearly than the published version of the paper, while it differs from the later version in that it does not contain many discussions of the "Formal Structures" paper, e.g. discussions on ethnomethodological indifference and glossing practices among others.
[1] June 6 "On 'Setting' in Conversation"
The text of the paper and other useful materials are on the materials page (password required). -> LINK
Part II. Roundtable on "Reasonable Accounts": transcripts of the talks delivered at Sixteenth Annual Conference on World Affairs, University of Colorado, April 11 and 12, 1963.
[2]
Harold Garfinkel "Mocking Up the Rules of Everyday Activities" Dear EMCA Seminar participants;
Garfinkel dealt with the following themes in this paper:
- Sociological theorizing as odd enterprise
- Social structures and sociological formulations
- Investigating the impact of sex norm in matching people
- Coates’ story of “The Law” (of the night the law of average fails)
- Two structures: achieved pattern and subject’s production
- Plastic engine (the concept of mock-up)
- Rules and norms as mock-ups of everyday activities used by sociologists
- Reasonable accounts as used by sociologists
- The concept of game rules being not-applicable as the rules for everyday activities:the odd temporary character. the irrelevance of personal character, the discrepancies between formal rules and actual actions
- Characteristics of everyday rules: et cetera (and so forth) clause, pretense of agreement, let it pass and unless, factum valet
- Announcement of the program of ethno-methodology
[3]
Harvey Sacks "More on Mock-Ups"
[4]
Egon Bittner "Ethical Symbols"
[5]
Harold Garfinkel "Reasonable Accounts"
[6]
Edward Rose, Harvey Sacks, Egon Bittner, and Harold Garfinkel "Translations"
Part III. PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USES (Draft - June 1960)
p.1 - p.9 Chapter I
p.10 - p.44 Chapter II INTRODUCTORY COMMENTS TO THE PROBLEM OF SOCIAL ORDER
p.45 - p.78 Chapter III THE PROBLEM OF SOCIAL ORDER
p.79 - p.120 Chapter IV "ADEQUATE' DESCRIPTIONS OF SOCIAL STRUCTURES
[NOTE: Garfinkel wrote at the end of Chapter IV "(Insert at this point a summary of the preceding four chapters so as to make a transition to Chapter V which presents an illustrative case of a structured analysis by Parsons.)"(p.120), then apparently inserted "preliminary draft February 8?, 1963 Parsons' Solution to the Problem of Social Order as a Method for Making Everyday Activities Observable 'From the Actor's Point of View'" (ending at p.179). So, p.1 - 3, p. 123 - p. 179 Preliminary Draft February 8, 1963 Parsons Solution to the Problem of Social Order as a Method for Making Everyday Activities Observable "From the Actor's Point of View" is inserted.
p.1 - p.47 Chapter ECONOMY, POLITY, MONEY, AND POWER
p.1 - p.29 Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT OF MATERIALS ON 1940 ARTICLE ON STRATIFICATION - AD HOC PARSONS
p.1 - p.41 Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT FOR ILLUSTRATIVE USE OF "STRUCTURED STRAIN"
p.1 - p.128 Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT AND NOTE FOR A CHAPTER ON VALUES
Additional Information:
(1) The change of schedule will be announced on this page.
(2) The class schedule may be changed considering the seminar participants' needs to present their own research to the class or by other contingencies; then the classes will move down accordingly.
(3) The Paper on "Parsons' Solution" was read in our 2014 seminar, so we will skip this part.
(4) On-line internet participation to the seminar will be possible via Skype or FaceTime depending on the Kobe University's network (KHAN)'s capacity. Please let me know about the expected on-line participation in advance for necessary arrangements.
(5) The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my sites: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology, and Ethnomethodology after 1970 - Suggestions and Informations to be added to these sites are welcomed.
(6) Changes and additions in this site will be announced on twitter and Facebook.
Materials:
-> 2016-17 Fall-WInter Seminar Materials (Password Required)
Additional Information:
MAP -> LINK to Kobe University Access Map (The "frontier" building is the building, No 29.)
While this is a credited course for the graduate students of legal sociology of Kobe University, anyone who is interested is welcome to attend (without credits).
2016
EMCA Seminar: Fall-Winter of 2016-17
13:30-15:30,Tuesdays, October 18, 2016 - April 18, 2017
Room 304, 3rd Floor, "the Frontier" Building,
Rokkodai-Campus, Kobe University
Shiro Kashimura
Professor, School of Law
Kobe University
Theme: Harold Garfinkel's Projects in early 1960's
The EMCA Seminar in Fall/Winter of 2016 focuses on Harold Garfinkel's unpublished seminar transcripts and conference papers in early 1960's. The materials include: Parsons' Primer (1960-63), Transcriptions of Ethnomethodology Seminar of September and October of 1962, Talks on "reasonable accounts" delivered by HG, Harvey Sacks, Egon Bittner & Edward Rose at the 16th World Affairs Conference, University of Colorado, 1963.
Texts of Garfinkel's Seminar of September 25, October 2 (part), and October 9, with some comments -> LINK
Part I. Garfinkel's Ethnomethodology Seminar of 1962
[1][2] October 18, 25
September 25, 1962
[3] [4] November 1, 8
October 2, 1962
[5][6] November 15, 22
October 9, 1962 File 1
[7] [8] November 29, December 6
October 9, 1962 File 2
[9] [10] December 13, 20
October 9, 1962 File 3
Texts of Garfinkel's Seminar of September 25, October 2 (part), and October 9, with some comments -> LINK
Garfinkel & Sacks 1967 On "Setting" in Conversation
Part II. Garfinkel (1960-63) PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USES (Draft - June 1960)
[11] January 10, 2017
p.1 - p.9 Chapter I
[12] January 17, 2017
p.10 - p.44 Chapter II INTRODUCTORY COMMENTS TO THE PROBLEM OF SOCIAL ORDER
[13] January 24
p.45 - p.78 Chapter III THE PROBLEM OF SOCIAL ORDER
[14] January 31
p.79 - p.120 Chapter IV "ADEQUATE' DESCRIPTIONS OF SOCIAL STRUCTURES
[NOTE: Garfinkel wrote at the end of Chapter IV "(Insert at this point a summary of the preceding four chapters so as to make a transition to Chapter V which presents an illustrative case of a structured analysis by Parsons.)"(p.120), then apparently inserted "preliminary draft February 8?, 1963 Parsons' Solution to the Problem of Social Order as a Method for Making Everyday Activities Observable 'From the Actor's Point of View'" (ending at p.179). So, p.1 - 3, p. 123 - p. 179 Preliminary Draft February 8, 1963 Parsons Solution to the Problem of Social Order as a Method for Making Everyday Activities Observable "From the Actor's Point of View" is inserted.
[15] February 7
p.1 - p.47 Chapter ECONOMY, POLITY, MONEY, AND POWER
[16] February 14
p.1 - p.29 Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT OF MATERIALS ON 1940 ARTICLE ON STRATIFICATION - AD HOC PARSONS
[17] February 21
p.1 - p.41 Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT FOR ILLUSTRATIVE USE OF "STRUCTURED STRAIN"
[18] [19] February 28, March 7
p.1 - p.128 Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT AND NOTE FOR A CHAPTER ON VALUES
Part III. Roundtable on "Reasonable Accounts": transcripts of the talks delivered at Sixteenth Annual Conference on World Affairs, University of Colorado, April 11 and 12, 1963.
[20] March 14
Harold Garfinkel "Mocking Up the Rules of Everyday Activities"
[21] March 21
Harvey Sacks "More on Mock-Ups"
[22] April 4
Egon Bittner "Ethical Symbols"
[23] April 11
Harold Garfinkel "Reasonable Accounts"
[24] April 18
Edward Rose, Harvey Sacks, Egon Bittner, and Harold Garfinkel "Translations"
Additional Information:
(1) The change of schedule will be announced on this page.
(2) The class schedule may be changed considering the seminar participants' needs to present their own research to the class or by other contingencies; then the classes will move down accordingly.
(3) The Paper on "Parsons' Solution" was read in 2014 seminar, so we will skip this part.
(4) On-line internet participation to the seminar will be possible via Skype or FaceTime depending on the Kobe University's network (KHAN)'s capacity. Please let me know about the expected on-line participation in advance for necessary arrangements.
(5) The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my sites: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology, and Ethnomethodology after 1970 - Suggestions and Informations to be added to these sites are welcomed.
(6) Changes and additions in this site will be announced on twitter and Facebook.
Materials:
-> 2016-17 Fall-WInter Seminar Materials (Password Required)
Additional Information:
MAP -> LINK to Kobe University Access Map (The "frontier" building is the building, No 29.)
While this is a credited course for the graduate students of legal sociology of Kobe University, anyone who is interested is welcome to attend (without credits).
2016
EMCA Seminar: Spring-Summer Quarters of 2016
13:30-16:30,Tuesdays, April 19 - July 26, 2016
Room 303, 3rd Floor, "Frontier" Building,
Rokkodai-Campus, Kobe University
Shiro Kashimura
Professor, School of Law
Kobe University
Theme: Harold Garfinkel's Projects: 1970-1990
The EMCA Seminar in Spring and Summer quarters of 2016 focuses on Harold Garfinkel's unpublished projects during the years of 1970s to 80s. Principally drawing on the unpublished drafts written by HG and his collaborators in the period, we shall examine and try to advance a deeper understanding of distinctive themes, methods, and reasonings of EM.
April 19 [1] Introduction
樫村「社会的世界の把握はいかにして可能か—エスノメソドロジーの失われた原問題をめぐって」(2016年3月23日、北海道大学法理論研究会報告」-> LINK (本文、図)
April 26 [2] Studies of Work
(Reading material to be provided for participants only)
May 10, 17, 24 [3] EM's Issues and Ways of Working
Harold Garfinkel "Sources of Issues and Ways of Working: An Introduction to the Study of Naturally Organized Ordinary Activities."
May 31, June 7, 14 [4] Natural Sciences
Harold Garfinkel, Eric Livingston, Michael Lynch, Douglas MacBeth, & Albert B. Robillard "Respecifying the Natural Sciences as Discovering Sciences of Practical Action, I & II: Doing So Ethnographically by Administering a Schedule of Contingencies in Discussions with Laboratory Scientists and by Hanging Around Their Laboratories (Selected Materials **)
July 5, 12, 19 [5] "Inter-sexed"l Persons and Their "Passing"
Norbert Wiley with Harold Garfinkel (March 31, 1980) "Discussion: (1) The Case of Agnes, (2) Why Do Ethnomethodologists Prefer to Talk about 'Production' Instead of 'Reality Construction."
July 26, August 2, 9 [6] Kids' Culture
Harold Garfinkel, George Girton, Eric Livingston, & Harvey Sacks, "Studies of Kids' Culture and Kids' Talk" (a project report) (1982?)
-> Course Materials (Password Required)
Additional Information:
The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my site: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology.
MAP -> LINK to Kobe University Access Map (The "frontier" building is the building, No 29.)
While this is a credited course for the graduate students of legal sociology of Kobe University, anyone who is interested is welcome to attend (without credits).
2015
テーマ:ガイダンス、言語、生活世界 Guidance, Language, and the Life-World
イントロダクションでは、アカウント、秩序などのEMCAのテーマのほか、1920年ごろのアメリカのハーレム・ルネサンスに関して議論します。第1部では、ズナニエツキの著作を素材にガイダンス行為について議論します。第2部では、ケネス・バークの著作を素材にEMCAが言語をどう捉えるかについて議論します。第3部では、人工的文化的な意味の世界としての生活世界の構造について、シュッツ、ギュルヴィッチ、ガーフィンケルの捉え方を検討します。
時間:毎週火曜日13:30-16:30 (最大限)
場所:神戸大学六甲台キャンパス第2学舎102号室
Scheduler:
Introduction to the Themes of the Seminar:
October 6 [1] 樫村「アカウントの社会学的解釈」(Kashimura (2015 forthcoming)
"Sociological Interpretation of Accounts") -> LINK
October 13 [2] 樫村「法社会学の対象と理論」(Kashimura (2015 forthcoming) "The
Objects and Theories of Sociology of Law") -> LINK
October 20 [3] Paul V. Murphy (2012) "Mulatto America," chapter 4 of
his The New Era: American Thought and Culture in the 1920s. (Rowman &
Littlefield Publishers Inc.): 109-147.
Part I: Guidance as a Type of Social Actions
October 27 [4] Florian Znaniecki (1936) "Educational Guidance,"
chapter VII of his Social Actions.(Farrar and Rinehart): 189-230.
November 3 (no class)
November 10 [5] Florian Znaniecki (1998) "Education for Democracy," a
chapter in his Education and Social Change (Frankfurt am Main, Peter
Lang GmbH): 41-121.
Part II: The Pragmatic Uses of Language
November 17,24[6] & [7] Kenneth Burke (1937) "Acceptance and
Rejection," the Part I of Attitudes Toward History. (University of
California Press): 3-107.
December 1 (no class)
December 8 [8] Kenneth Burke (1966) "Poetics in Particular, Language
in General (1961)," in his Language as Symbolic Action: Essays on
Life, Literature and Method.(University of California Press): 25-43.
Part III: The Life-World as Group's Practices and Objects
December 15, 22 [9] & [10] Alfred Schutz & Thomas Luckmann (1983) "The
Life-World as the Province of Practice," chapter 5 of The Structures
of the Life-World, Volume II. (Northwestern University Press.): 1-97.
January 5 [11] Aron Gurwitsch "The Perceptual Process'" in The
Collected Works of Aron Gurwitsch (1901-1973). Volume III: The Field
of Consciousness: Theme, Thematic Field, and Margin. Springer:
195-219.
January 12 [12] Harold Garfinkel (1949) "Style, Tactics, and
Strategies of Communication," "Group," & "Specific Problems," in his
Seeing Sociologically: Routine Grounds of Social Action. (Paradigm
Publishers): 182-216..
January 19 [13] Harold Garfinkel (1952) "Theory of the Object," in his
Perception of the Other: A Study in Social Order.
(Ph.D.Thesis):284-315.
2015
EMCA Seminar
Spring-Summer of 2015
Shiro Kashimura
Professor, School of Law
Kobe University
Theme: Life-Worlds, Immigration and Cultural Reflection
The Spring-Summer term of 2015 EMCA Seminar considers such complex interactional phenomena as deviant career, ethnicity, immigration and cultural confrontation. On the way, we will examine them as the phenomena of the Life-World. The seminar will start with considering the concept of "definition of situation" then "career of individual" through the subjective sociology of William I. Thomas. Then we examine the phenomena of immigration, national culture, and universalistic individualism of modern society through the works by Morawska, Znaniecki, and Parsons. We shall examine the complexity of Life-World phenomena of Drama through the early work of Schutz, and the concepts of bodily reflection as Marginal Consciousness through the work of Gurwitsch. After examining the two stages of Schutz's life to place his theory in German and American intellectual contexts, we try to learn the relationship of the life-world knowledge and the society at large.
Materials for the Seminar: (教材の順番を変更しました。2015.6.2)
[1] 相互反映性の原則の学説史的起源 -> LINK
[2] Chapter 1 "The Wishes" and Chapter 2 "The Regulation of the Wishes" of The Unadjusted Girl: With Cases and Standpoint for Behavioral Analysis (1923) by William I. Thomas, Little Brown & Company: 1 - 69. (The book is available online.)
[3] Chapter 1 of Ewa Morawska For Bread with Butter:The Life-Worlds of East Central Europeans in Johnstown, Pennsylvania, 1890-1940 (Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Modern History) 1986.
[4] Chapter 1 of Florian Znaniecki Modern Nationalities 1973.
[5] Talcott Parsons "Individuality and Institutionalized Individualism." Chapter 10 of American Society: A Theory of the Societal Community (edited by Giuseppe Sciortino), Paradigm Publishers, 2007.
[6] Alfred Schutz "Meaning Structure of Drama and Opera" in Life Forms and Meaning Structure. Translated by Helmut R. Wagner. Rutledge, 1982: 180-207.
[7] Michael D. Barber, "Social Science and Philosophy (1919-38): Weber and Bergson" Chapter 2 of The Participating Citizen: A Biography of Alfred Schutz. SUNY Press. 2004: 25-39
[8] Michael D. Barber "The Years 1952 to 1956: Philosophical Midwifery; Correspondence and Research" of The Participating Citizen: A Biography of Alfred Schutz. SUNY Press. 2004: 167-80.
[9] Alfred Schutz & Thomas Luckmann "Knowledge and Society" in The Structures of the Life-World. Northwestern University Press, 1973: 243-331.
[10] Aron Gurwitsch "Marginal Consciousness" in The Collected Works of Aron Gurwitsch (1901-1973). Volume III: The Field of Consciousness, Springer.: 451-537.
[11] Aron Gurwitsch "Outline of a Theory of 'Essentially Occasioned Expressions'" in The Collected Works of Aron Gurwitsch (1901-1973). Volume III: The Field of Consciousness, Springer: 451-537.
-> Course Materials (Password Required)
Additional Information:
The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my site: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology.
Time & Place:
The class will meet in Room 302 of Frontier Building at 13:30-16:30 (the ending time depending on the discussion) on every Tuesday starting on April 14, 2015.
Whereas this is a credited course for the graduate students of legal sociology of Kobe University, anyone who is interested is welcome to attend (without credits).
2014
EMCA Seminar Fall-Winter 2014:
Knowledge, Consciousness, and Action
Professor Shiro Kashimura
Graduate School of Law
Kobe University
Purpose
The Fall-Winter term of 2014 EMCA Seminar will examine the basic building blocks of the idea of Ethnomethodology: Knowledge, Consciousness, and Action. Its first part considering the materials by Helmer & Rescher, and by Mannheim introduces the concepts of "accounting" and "documentary method of interpretation" among the Garfinkel's idea of ethnomethodology. The question of the connectedness of accounting and knowledge will be pursued by reading 2 addtitonal materials focusing on the working concept of "information," Garfinkel's 1952 manuscript (published in 2006) and J.S.Bruner's paper. The second part of the seminar tries to clarify the question of how knowledge reflectively connect themselves within the system of practical-action. The first 2 materials by Hinkle and by Hawthorn inform us of the background of Americal sociology at the time. The materials by Znaniecki, Schütz, Gurwitsch, and Burke are the group of manifestations of European-American thought as to the concept of practical actions that were important not only for Garfinkel but also for the development of American sociology, much of which is forgotten by the current sociaological thoughts. We conclude with a "conceptual" analysis of Parsons' theory by a Dutch sociologist and his former student, Hans Adriaansens.
Materials for the Seminar:
On the Epistemology of the Inexact Sciences (1958) by Olaf Helmer and Nicholas Rescher, Rand Corporation. (The booklet is available online.)
"On the Interpretation of Weltanschauung" (1952)[=1921-22] by Karl Mannheim Essays on the Sociology of Knowledge, Tr. and ed. by Paul Kecskemeti (New York:Oxford U.P.): 33-83. (The chapter is available online.)
Toward a Sociological Theory of Information (1952) by Harold Garfinkel: pp. 110-159.
"Going Beyond the Information Given"(1957) by Jerome S. Bruner in his Beyond the Information Given, selected & edited by Jeremy M. Anglin, London, George Allen & Unwin: pp. 218-238.
"Possible European Influence on American Theory," (1994) a chapter by Roscoe C. Hinkle, in his Developments in American Sociological Theory, 1915-1950, SUNY Press: pp. 273-300.
"History Ignored" & "History Unresolved," chapters by G. Hawthorn (1987) , in his Enlightment and Despair: A History of Social Theory,Cambridge University Press: pp. 191-253.
"Cooperative Guidance" & "Primary Opposition," (1936) chapters by Florian Znaniecki , in his Social Actions, pp. 162-179, 312-344.
The Social Role of the Man of Knowledge (1940) by Florian Znaniecki .
"Reflections on the Problem of Relevance," (1945) by Alfred Schuetz in his Collected Papers V. Phenomenology and the Social Sciences, edited by Lester Embree, Springer: pp. 93-199
"Some Principles of Gestalt Psychology," (1953=1962) by A. Gurwitsch , in his The Collected Works of Aron Gurwitsch (1901-1973) Volume III, edited by Richard Zaner, Springer: pp. 86-148.
"Scope and Reduction," by Kenneth Burke (1945), A Grammar of Motives: pp. 58-125 (The book is available online reading.)
"The New Voluntaristic Action Theory," & "Testing The Theory Against Its Premises," (1980) chapters by H.P.M. Adriaansens in his Talcott Parsons and the Conceptual Dilemma, Routledge & Kegan Paul: pp. 116-175.
Additional Information:
The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my site: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology.
Time & Place:
The class will meet in Room 102 of Law Building at 13:30-15:50 (the ending time depending on the discussion) on every Tuesday starting on October 11, 2014.
Whereas this is a credited course for the graduate students of legal sociology of Kobe University, anyone who is interested is welcome to attend (without credits).
2014
EMCA Seminar 2014 : Garfinkel's Early Works
Professor Shiro Kashimura
Graduate School of Law
Kobe University
In the Spring-Summer term of 2014 we would like to examine the papers written by Harold Garfinkel in the years prior to the seminal publication of Studies in Ethnomethodology (1967). The papers include "Inter- and Intra-racial Homicide" (1949), "Sociological Concepts and Methods for Psychiatrists"(1956), "Status Degradations" (1956), the selected chapters of The Perception of the Other: A Study in Social Order (1952) and Toward a Sociological Theory of Information (1952=2008), and some unpublished manuscripts. We shall look for the developments and influences up to the crystalization of the ideas of ethnomethodology around1954 and in the preceding and the following years. We shall conclude with considering the responses by sociologists in U.S. and elsewhere to the publication using the review articles and excerpts from The Purdue Symposium on Ethnomethodology in 1968.
The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my site: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology.
The class will meet in Room 406 of “Frontier” Building at 10:40-14:50 (the ending time depending on the discussion) on every Tuesday starting on May 13, 2014.
2013
EMCA Seminar 2013-14 : On Symbolic Actions
Professor Shiro Kashimura
Graduate School of Law
Kobe University
In this term of 2013-2014 we would like to examine the organization and varieties of “symbolic actions” -- social actions which utilize the member's competency of using words heavily as its means, environments, and restraints. We begin by examining the theory of symbolic action by Kenneth Burke, then move on to 2 of the explication of Husserl’s theory of meaning and experience by Marvin Farber. Then we examine the phenomenological analysis of horizon by Helmut Kuhn and sociological analysis of invitation/enticement by Znaniecki. We will conclude by examining two analyses from contemporary EMCA -- the analysis of reading by Livingston followed by that of game-player’s rule-following by Liberman.
The class will meet in Room 405 of “Frontier” Building at 13:20-14:50 (or 10:40 am - 12:20 pm for some days) on every Thursday. There will be no class on October 17 due to my travelling, however. (Class hours information is corrected. 2013.10.3)
2013
The EMCA Seminar of 2013’s Summer considers the effects of phenomenology and sociology in the early 20th century of the US on Harold Garfinkel’s thought that eventually led to ethnomethodology by 1950s. Especially the seminar focuses on Florian Znaniecki’s move toward sociology and Husserl’s criticism of reason, as developed by Aron Gurwitsch & Alfred Schütz, with the aim of clarifying the operation of major intellectual forces of the time that moulded the epistemological tenet of ethnomethodology as a new way of studying society.
The seminar begins at Znaniecki’s sociological thought that presumably conveyed the European sociological/philosophical thinking to the US and its impacts on American sociology of the time. It is followed by the works in American development/transmission of phenomenology by such European/Exile thinkers as Schütz, Gurwitsch, Farber, and Kaufman from the early years up to the middle of 20th century. The seminar concludes with reading a chapter from Garfinkel’s Seeing Sociologically (1948) and a chapter from Liberman's recent book, Husserl's Criticism of Reason (2007).
The class meets on Tuesdays (10:40am - 12:10pm) according to the schedule that follows at Room 102 of the Law Faculty's Building II, Rokkodai, Kobe University. (The Building is no. 4 on this Map of Kobe University)
On chronological list of publications in the formative era (1934 - 1967) of ethnomethodology and phenomenology in America, visit the link.
For this course's reading materials visit here (restricted to students).
THE READING MATERIALS (updated, 2013/05/28)
2012
2012 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Seminar on Ethnomethodology and Conversation Analysis
(April-July 2011, Thursdays, 1:20 p.m. - 4:30 p.m.
Location: TBA )
Class Schedule and List of Readings
ReadingTwo Books on Understanding,Language
and Interacting Bodies
In this term of the seminar, we will read two books on understanding, language and interacting bodies, David Goode’s A World Without Words (1994), and Albert B. Robillard’s Meaning of Disability (2003), by reading one or two chapters a week alternately. We shall think about how human communications are done in practically possible and reliable ways through embedded presentation of words and bodies along with other contingent and ever-developing features of action-in-a-scene.
[ 1] (4.14)
Goode 1994:1-6
Translation Goode Foreword, Acknowledgments
Translation Goode Introduction
Robillard 2003: ix-xv
Translation Acknowledgments
[ 2] (4.21)
“Construction and Use of Data in Social Science Research”
Goode 1994:96-124 (Chapter 5)
Translation Goode Chapter 5
[ 3] (4.28)
"Can He Think?”, “The Trip”
Robillard 2003:145-184 (Chapters 8 & 9)
Translation Chapters 8
Translation Chapter 9 (未)
[ 4] (5.12)
“A World Without Words”
Goode 1994:7-46 (Chapter 2)
Translation Goode Chapter 2
[ 5] (5.19)
“You Are Lucky Your Wife Stuck With You”
Robillard 2003:35-47. (Chapter 2)
Translation Robillard Chapter 2
[ 6] (5.26)
“On Understanding Without Words”
Goode 1994:47-95 (Chapter 3)
Translation Goode Chapter 3 pp. 47-95
[ 7] (6.2)
“Communicating in Intensive Care”
Robillard 2003:48-63 (Chapter 3)
Translation Robillard Chapter 3
[ 8] (6.9)
“Kids, Culture, and Innocent”
Goode 1994:165-191. (Chapter 6)
Translation Goode Chapter 6
Mannoni, O. 1972 “Itard and His Savage”
[ 9] (6.16)
“Anger”, “Tragic Narratives”
Robillard 2003:64-81, 110-122 (Chapters 4 & 6)
Translation Robillard Chapter 4
Translation Robillard Chapter 6
[10] (6.23)
“Reflections 0n the Possibility of Understanding Without Formal Language”
Goode 1994:96-124 (Chapter 4)
Translation Goode Chapter 4
[11] (6.30)
“Isolation”
Robillard 2003: 82-109 (Chapter 5)
Translation Robillard Chapter 5
[12] (7.7)
“Conclusions”, “Appendix”
Goode 1994: 192-216
Translation Goode Conclusion
Translation Goode Appendix
[13] (7.14)
”Bionic Man”
Robillard 2003: 82-109 (Chapter 7)
Translation Robillard Chapter 7
Source:
David Goode (1994) A World Without Words: The Social Construction of Children Born Deaf and Blind (Temple University Press)
Albert B. Robillard (2003) Meaning of Disability: The Lived Experience of Paralysis (Temple University Press)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2011
Morality of Rules and Laws
今学期の趣旨について
I. Visibility of Morality
[ 1] (10.7)
Harold Garfinkel
"Role and the Concept of the Finite Province of Meaning"
in Harold Garfinkel, Seeing Sociologically 2006: 107-132.
1 Garfinkel.pdf
抄訳
Major Events in H.G.’s Early Years
[ 2] (10.14)
David Sudnow
"Normal Crimes: Sociological Features of the Penal Code in a Public Defender Office"
in Social Problems, Vol. 12, No. 3 (Winter, 1965), pp. 255-276
2 Sudnow.pdf
抄訳
[ 3] (10.21)
Harvey Sacks
"Notes on Police Assessment of Moral Character"
in David Sudnow, ed. Studies in Social Interaction (1972): 280-293
3 Sacks.pdf
翻訳 [岡田光弘さんの訳です]
第2版 [岡田さんの訳にもとづき、樫村が気づいたところの改訂を試みました]
[ 4] (10.28)
John Heritage
"Conversation Analysis and Institutional Talk"
in Kristine L. Fitch & Robert E. Sanders, eds. Handbook of Language and Social Interaction 2005: 103-147.
4 Heritage.pdf
抄訳
II. Morality of Social Roles
[ 5] (11.4)
Jim Schenkein
"Identity Negotiations in Conversation"
in Jim Schenkein, ed. Studies in the Organization of Conversational Interaction 1978: 57-78.
5 Schenkein.pdf
抄訳
[ 6] (11.11)
D. R. Watson
"Some Features of the Elicitation of Confessions in Murder Interrogations"
in George Psathas, ed. Interaction Competence 1990: 263-295
6 Watson.pdf
抄訳
[ 7] (11.18)
Martha Komter
"Remorse, Redress, and Reform: Blame-Taking in the Courtroom"
in Max Travers & John F. Manzo, eds. Law in Action: Ethnomethodological and Conversation Analytic Approaches to Law 1997: 239-97.
7 Komter.pdf
抄訳
[ 8] (11.25)
J. Maxwell Atkinson & Paul Drew
"The Production of Justifications and Excuses by Witnesses in Cross-Examination"
in J. Maxwell Atkinson & Paul Drew Order in Court: The Organisation of Verbal Interaction in Judicial Settings. 1979: 136-187
8 Atkinson & Drew.pdf
参考: 「血の日曜日」事件について -> THE BLOODY SUNDAY TRIBUNAL OF INQUIRY
抄訳
[ 9] (12.2)
Anita Pomerantz & Jenny Mandelbaum
"Conversation Analytic Approaches to the Relevance and Uses of Relationship Categories in Interaction"
in Kristine L. Fitch & Robert E. Sanders, eds. Handbook of Language and Social Interaction 2005: 149-171
9 Pomerantz & Mandelbaum.pdf
抄訳
III. Telling Stories as Moral Act
[ 10] (12.9)
Michael Moerman
"The Use of Precedent in Natural Conversation: A Study in Practical Legal Reasoning" (1973)
in Michael Lynch & Wes Sharrock, eds. Harold Garfinkel 2003 Vol.3: 371-393.
10 Moerman.pdf
抄訳
[ 11] (12.16)
D. R. Watson
"Interdisciplinary Considerations in the Analysis of Pro-Terms"
in Graham Button & John R. E. Lee, eds. Talk and Social Organisation 1987: 261-289
11 Watson.pdf
抄訳
[ 12] (1.13)
Anita Pomerantz
"Descriptions in Legal Settings"
in Graham Button & John R. E. Lee, eds. Talk and Social Organisation 1987: 226-243
12 Pomerantz.pdf
抄訳
[13] (1.20)
Harvey Sacks
"Some Technical Considerations of a Dirty Joke"
in Jim Schenkein, ed. Studies in the Organizatoin of Conversational Interaction. 1978 : 249-269.
13 Sacks.pdf
抄訳
[14] (1.27)
Wes Sharrock & Roy Turner
"On a Conversational Environment of Equivocality"
in Jim Schenkein, ed. Studies in the Organizatoin of Conversational Interaction. 1978 : 173-197.
14 Sharrock & Turner.pdf
抄訳
2011
Seminar on Ethnomethodology and Conversation Analysis
(April-July 2011, Thursdays, 1:20 p.m. - 4:30 p.m.
Location: TBA )
Class Schedule and List of Readings
ReadingTwo Books on Understanding,Language
and Interacting Bodies
In this term of the seminar, we will read two books on understanding, language and interacting bodies, David Goode’s A World Without Words (1994), and Albert B. Robillard’s Meaning of Disability (2003), by reading one or two chapters a week alternately. We shall think about how human communications are done in practically possible and reliable ways through embedded presentation of words and bodies along with other contingent and ever-developing features of action-in-a-scene.
[ 1] (4.14)
Goode 1994:1-6
Translation Goode Foreword, Acknowledgments
Translation Goode Introduction
Robillard 2003: ix-xv
Translation Acknowledgments
[ 2] (4.21)
“Construction and Use of Data in Social Science Research”
Goode 1994:96-124 (Chapter 5)
Translation Goode Chapter 5
[ 3] (4.28)
"Can He Think?”, “The Trip”
Robillard 2003:145-184 (Chapters 8 & 9)
Translation Chapters 8
Translation Chapter 9 (未)
[ 4] (5.12)
“A World Without Words”
Goode 1994:7-46 (Chapter 2)
Translation Goode Chapter 2
[ 5] (5.19)
“You Are Lucky Your Wife Stuck With You”
Robillard 2003:35-47. (Chapter 2)
Translation Robillard Chapter 2
[ 6] (5.26)
“On Understanding Without Words”
Goode 1994:47-95 (Chapter 3)
Translation Goode Chapter 3 pp. 47-95
[ 7] (6.2)
“Communicating in Intensive Care”
Robillard 2003:48-63 (Chapter 3)
Translation Robillard Chapter 3
[ 8] (6.9)
“Kids, Culture, and Innocent”
Goode 1994:165-191. (Chapter 6)
Translation Goode Chapter 6
Mannoni, O. 1972 “Itard and His Savage”
[ 9] (6.16)
“Anger”, “Tragic Narratives”
Robillard 2003:64-81, 110-122 (Chapters 4 & 6)
Translation Robillard Chapter 4
Translation Robillard Chapter 6
[10] (6.23)
“Reflections 0n the Possibility of Understanding Without Formal Language”
Goode 1994:96-124 (Chapter 4)
Translation Goode Chapter 4
[11] (6.30)
“Isolation”
Robillard 2003: 82-109 (Chapter 5)
Translation Robillard Chapter 5
[12] (7.7)
“Conclusions”, “Appendix”
Goode 1994: 192-216
Translation Goode Conclusion
Translation Goode Appendix
[13] (7.14)
”Bionic Man”
Robillard 2003: 82-109 (Chapter 7)
Translation Robillard Chapter 7
Source:
David Goode (1994) A World Without Words: The Social Construction of Children Born Deaf and Blind (Temple University Press)
Albert B. Robillard (2003) Meaning of Disability: The Lived Experience of Paralysis (Temple University Press)
2009
Theme: Rule, Reason and Reality
I. Rules, Action and Reality
[ 1] Accounting by Rule
D.L. Wieder
"Rules as Explanation of Action"
in Wieder (1974) 29-45
Wieder_Ch1.pdf Wieder_Bibliography.pdf 訳 コメント
[ 2] Rule and Activity
D.L.Wieder
"Persuasion and Reflexive Formulation"
in Wieder (1974) 167-182
Wieder_Ch6.pdf 訳 コメント
[ 3] Perception through Accounting by Rule
D.L.Wieder
"'Telling the Code' as a Guide to Perception: The Inner Structure of Social Reality"
in Wieder (1974) 183-214
Wieder_Ch7.pdf 訳 コメント
[ 4] From Rule to Society
D.L.Wieder "'Telling the Code' as an Exhibition of Order"
in Wieder (1974) 215-224
Wieder Ch8.pdf 訳 コメント
D.H.Zimmerman "Preface"
in Wieder (1974) 9-26
Wieder_Preface.pdf 訳 コメント
II. Reason-in-Action
[ 5] What Is Ethnomethodology?
H.Garfinkel
"Author's Introduction"
Introduction.pdf 訳 コメント
"Author's Acknowledgements as an Autobiographical Account"
Acknowledgement.pdf 訳 コメント
"The Central Claims of Ethnomethodology"
CentralClaims.pdf 訳 コメント
in Garfinkel (2002) 65-120
[ 6] Formal Theorizing on/as/in the Social Order
H.Garfinkel (with E.Bittner)
"Methodological Adequacy in the Quantitative Study of Selection Criteria and Selection Activities in Psychiatric Outpatient Clinics"
in Garfinkel (1967)
Garfinkel & Bittner 1967.pdf Garfinkel with Bittner 1967.txt 訳 コメント
[ 7] Doing a Sociology
M.D.Baccus
"Sociological Indication and the Validity Criterion of Real World Social Theorizing"
in Garfinkel (ed.) (1986) 1-19
Baccus 1986.pdf テキスト版 訳 コメント
[ 8] Regulating
M.D.Baccus
"Multipiece Truck Wheel Accidents and Their Regulations"
in Garfinkel (ed.) (1986) 20-59
Baccus Regulation.pdf テキスト版 訳 コメント
参考資料 OSHAのすべて Multi-Piece Rim Accident Booklet
ホイール構造の図解(http://www.tyrelandweb.com/wheel/kouzou.html)
[ 9] Instruction Following
H.Garfinkel
"Instructions and Instructed Actions"
in Garfinkel (2002) 197-218
Instructions.pdf テキスト版 英文要約 コメント
[ 10] Teaching
H.Garfinkel
"A Study of the Work of Teaching Undergraduate Chemistry in Lecture Format"
in Garfinkel (2002) 219-244 Chapter7.pdf Chapter Seven.txt 抄訳 コメント
[ 11] Queueing
H.Garfinkel
"Autochthonous Order Properties of Formatted Queues"
in Garfinkel (2002) 245-261 Chapter8.pdf Chapter Eight.txt 抄訳 コメント
参考資料:7月4日のパレードの竹馬男 (http://www.sxc.hu/photo/135105)
[ 12] Doing a Scientific Demonstration
H.Garfinkel
"An Ethnomethodological Study of the Work of Calileo's Inclined Plane Demonstration of the Real Motion of Free Falling Bodies"
in Garfinkel (2002) 263-285 Chapter9.pdf Chapter Nine.txt 訳 コメント
Sources:
D.L.Wieder (1974) Language and Social Reality: The Case of Telling Convict Code. Mouton, The Hague.
H.Garfinkel (1967) Studies in Ethnomethodology. Prentice-Hall.
H.Garfinkel ed. (1986) Ethnomethodological Studies of Work. Routledge & Kegan Paul.
H.Garfinkel (2002) Ethnomethodology's Program. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
2009
Seminar on Ethnomethodology and Conversation Analysis (2009 April-July Fridays, 1:20 p.m.- #102)
Class Schedule and List of Readings (カッコ内は予定日)
I. What is Ethnomethodology
(4.17) M. Moerman & H. Sacks, On Understanding in the Analysis of Natural Conversation. 1971
教材-> Moerman&Sacks_1971.pdf 試訳 注釈
(4.24) M.Peyrot, Understanding Ethnomethodology: A Remedy for Some Common Misconceptions 1982
-> Peyrot 1982.pdf 抄訳 注釈
(5.1) 大学院生研究発表会のため休講
(5.8) 法社会学会(明治大学)のため休講
II. Norms and Categories in Competent Understanding of Society
(5.15) E.Bittner, The Concept of Organization. 1965
-> Bittner 1965.pdf 試訳 注釈
(5.29) E.Bittner, The Police on Skid-Row: A Study of Peace Keeping. 1967
-> Bittner 1967.pdf 要約 抄訳 注釈
(6.5) 大学院生研究発表会のため休講
(6.12) E.Bittner, Objectivity and Realism in Sociology. 1973
-> Bittner 1973.pdf 試訳 注釈
(6.19) P. Drew. Accusations: The Occasioned Use of Member's Knowledge of 'Religious Geography' in Describing Events. 1978
-> Drew 1978.pdf 英文要約 試訳 注釈
(6.26) D.A.Goode, On Understanding Without Words: Communication Between a Deaf-Blind Child and her Parents. 1990
-> Goode_1990.pdf 英文要約 試訳 注釈
III. Variety of Organized Perceptions
(7.3) John O'Neil, From Phenomenology to Ethnomethodology: Some Radical 'Misreadings' 1980
-> Oneil 1980.pdf 試訳 注釈
(7.24) R.J.Anderson, J.A.Hughes & W.W.Sharrock, The Relationship Between Ethnomethodology and Phenomenology. 1985
-> Anderson Hughes Sharrock 1985.pdf 試訳 注釈
(7.31) A.V.Cicourel, Interviews, Surveys, and the Problem of Ecological Validity. 1982
-> Cicourel 1982.pdf 試訳 注釈
(8.7) L. Suchman and Brigitte Jordan, Interactional Troubles in Face-to-face Survey Interviews. 1990
-> Suchman Jordan 1990.pdf 試訳 注釈
(9.3) J. Coulter & E.D.Parsons, The Praxiology of Perception: Visual Orientations and Practical Action. 1991
-> Coulter Parsons 1991.pdf 試訳 注釈
2008
2008.10.9
D.L.Wieder 1988 From Resource to Topic: Some Aims of Conversation Analysis (part) 268-275
Wieder1988.pdf
2008.10.16
D.H.Zimmerman & D.L.Wieder 1971 Ethnomethodology and the Problem of Order (part)
Zimmerman&Wieder1971.pdf Zimmerman&Wieder1971要約.pdf
2008.10.23
H.Sacks 1963 Sociological Description (part) 204-209
Sacks1963.pdf Sacks1963_試訳.pdf
2008.10.30
A.W.Rawls 1999 Harold Garfinkel (part) 18-26
Rawls1999.pdf Rawls_1999_J.pdf
2008.11.13
D.H.Zimmerman & M.Pollner Everyday World as a Phenomenon (part) 206-215
Zimmerman&Pollner1971.pdf Z&P_Notes.pdf Zimmerman&Pollner_J.pdf
2008.11.20
H. Garfinkel 1964 Studies of the Routine Grounds of Everyday Life (part)
Garfinkel1964.pdf Garfinkel_1964_J.pdf
2008.11.27
G. Psathas 1979 Organizational Features of Direction Maps
Psathas1979.pdf tPsathas_1979_J.pdf
2008.12.04
R. Hilbert 1992 The Status of Rules in Normal Life (Chapter 2 of Classical Roots of Ethnomethodology)
Hilbert1992.pdf Hilbert_1992_j.pdf
2008.12.18
山崎晶子・菅靖子 2004 博物館研究
Yamazaki_2004.pdf
江原由美子 1985 服装の社会学
江原1985.pdf
EMCA Seminar: Fall of 2017 - Winter of 2018
Time: Tuesdays, 13:20-16:40
Place: Room304, 3rd Floor, "the Frontier" Building, Rokkodai-Campus, Kobe University
Shiro Kashimura
Professor, School of Law
Kobe University
Theme: Garfinkel and Sacks as Collaborators
The EMCA Seminar in Fall of 2017 and Winter of 2018 continues the interests of Spring-Summer of 2017 with additional focus on the collaboration of Garfinkel and Sacks in 1960's. They met during Garfinkel's stay at Harvard from 1959-60, and presumably their collaboration started in 1959. We already saw that Sacks's work and his insights began to be mentioned from the very early materials of Garfinkel's Ethnomethodology Seminars at UCLA (their transcripts are available since February, 1962). We shall continue to look at the papers from the roundtable session on "Reasonable Accounts" by Garfinkel, Sacks, Bittner & Rose at the 16th World Affairs Conference, University of Colorado, 1963, where in some papers delivered by Sacks his experience with law, children, and classical studies of logic, his ways of reading conversational materials were mentioned. In addition, the planned materials for our seminar include Sacks's published works:some of the Sacks's Lectures on Conversation (the transcripts in this book start in 1964 at UCLA) , and some early papers and corresponding lectures by Sacks.
Part I. Introduction to the Problems
[1] September 19 Introduction: the perspective on gloss/reasonable account, activity, the law and other subjects
- 樫村 1992 「法律的探求の社会組織」
Part II. Roundtable on "Reasonable Accounts": transcripts of the talks delivered at Sixteenth Annual Conference on World Affairs, University of Colorado, April 11 and 12, 1963.
[2] October 3 Harold Garfinkel "Mocking Up the Rules of Everyday Activities"
October 24 Reviewing Garfinkel's Mocking Up paper & Comparing it with "Trust" paper
[3] Harvey Sacks "More on Mock-Ups"
- 樫村「1960年代のGarfinkelと『エスノメソドロジー研究』」日本社会学会第90回大会テーマセッション(6) 「エスノメソドロジーと会話分析の半世紀(1)」(2017年11月4日・東京大学) ー> LINK
[4] Harold Garfinkel "Reasonable Accounts"
[5] Egon Bittner "Ethical Symbols"
[6] Edward Rose, Harvey Sacks, Egon Bittner, and Harold Garfinkel "Translations"
Part III The EM-Perspective on Social Structure
[7] Garfinkel 1960 Chapter IV "ADEQUATE' DESCRIPTIONS OF SOCIAL STRUCTURES,PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USESp.79 - p.120.
[8] Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT FOR ILLUSTRATIVE USE OF "STRUCTURED STRAIN",PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USES, p.1 - p.41
[9] Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT AND NOTE FOR A CHAPTER ON VALUES,,PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USES p.1 - p.128
Part IV Harvey Sacks as the Collaborator
[10] Sacks 1999, Harvey "Max Weber's Ancient Judaism" Theory, Culture & Society 16:31. -> LINK
[11] Schegloff 1999, Sacks on Weber and Ancient Judaism
[12] Sacks 1984, Notes on Methodology
[13] Sacks 1968, Search for Help
Additional Information:
(1) The change of schedule will be announced on this page.
(2) The class schedule may be changed considering the seminar participants' needs to present their own research to the class or by other contingencies; then the classes will move down accordingly.
(3) On-line internet participation to the seminar will be possible via Skype or FaceTime depending on the Kobe University's network (KHAN)'s capacity. Please let me know about the expected on-line participation in advance for necessary arrangements.
(4) The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my sites: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology, and Ethnomethodology after 1970 - Suggestions and Informations to be added to these sites are welcomed.
(5) Changes and additions in this site will be announced on twitter and Facebook.
Materials:(Password Required)
-> 2017-18 Seminar Materials
-> 2017 Spring-Summer Materials
-> 2016-17 Fall-WInter Seminar Materials
Additional Information:
MAP -> LINK to Kobe University Access Map (The "frontier" building is the building, No 29.)
While this is a credited course for the graduate students of legal sociology of Kobe University, anyone who is interested is welcome to attend (without credits).
2017
EMCA Seminar: Spring-Summer of 2017
Time: 15:10-17:00,Tuesdays
Place: Room 303, 3rd Floor, "the Frontier" Building, Rokkodai-Campus, Kobe University
Shiro Kashimura
Professor, School of Law
Kobe University
Theme: Ethnomethodology outside the Studies in 1960's
The EMCA Seminar in Spring/Summer of 2017 continues the 2016 seminar and further examines Harold Garfinkel's unpublished works in 1960's. They were not included in the Studies in Ethnomethodology (Garfinkel 1967) possibly or apparently for some reasons. The materials include: a collaborated paper by Garfinkel and Harvey Sacks, "On 'Setting' in Conversation"delivered at ASA San Francisco Annual Meeting, Section on Sociolinguistics, on August 31, 1967: the papers from the roundtable session on "Reasonable Accounts" by Garfinkel, Sacks, Egon Bittner & Edward Rose at the 16th World Affairs Conference, University of Colorado, 1963: and Parsons' Primer (1960-63) .
Part I. On "Setting" in Conversation
"On 'Setting' in Conversation" (Garfinkel & Sacks, 1967) is a paper read at the Sociolinguistic Section of ASA San Francisco Annual Meeting and is mentioned in "Formal Structures of Practical Actions" (Garfinkel & Sacks, 1969, 1986) as its early version. The content of the paper in large part overlaps with the "Formal Structures" paper but differs in that it focuses on the issue of repairing the indexicals more clearly than the published version of the paper, while it differs from the later version in that it does not contain many discussions of the "Formal Structures" paper, e.g. discussions on ethnomethodological indifference and glossing practices among others.
[1] June 6 "On 'Setting' in Conversation"
The text of the paper and other useful materials are on the materials page (password required). -> LINK
Part II. Roundtable on "Reasonable Accounts": transcripts of the talks delivered at Sixteenth Annual Conference on World Affairs, University of Colorado, April 11 and 12, 1963.
[2]
Harold Garfinkel "Mocking Up the Rules of Everyday Activities" Dear EMCA Seminar participants;
Garfinkel dealt with the following themes in this paper:
- Sociological theorizing as odd enterprise
- Social structures and sociological formulations
- Investigating the impact of sex norm in matching people
- Coates’ story of “The Law” (of the night the law of average fails)
- Two structures: achieved pattern and subject’s production
- Plastic engine (the concept of mock-up)
- Rules and norms as mock-ups of everyday activities used by sociologists
- Reasonable accounts as used by sociologists
- The concept of game rules being not-applicable as the rules for everyday activities:the odd temporary character. the irrelevance of personal character, the discrepancies between formal rules and actual actions
- Characteristics of everyday rules: et cetera (and so forth) clause, pretense of agreement, let it pass and unless, factum valet
- Announcement of the program of ethno-methodology
[3]
Harvey Sacks "More on Mock-Ups"
[4]
Egon Bittner "Ethical Symbols"
[5]
Harold Garfinkel "Reasonable Accounts"
[6]
Edward Rose, Harvey Sacks, Egon Bittner, and Harold Garfinkel "Translations"
Part III. PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USES (Draft - June 1960)
p.1 - p.9 Chapter I
p.10 - p.44 Chapter II INTRODUCTORY COMMENTS TO THE PROBLEM OF SOCIAL ORDER
p.45 - p.78 Chapter III THE PROBLEM OF SOCIAL ORDER
p.79 - p.120 Chapter IV "ADEQUATE' DESCRIPTIONS OF SOCIAL STRUCTURES
[NOTE: Garfinkel wrote at the end of Chapter IV "(Insert at this point a summary of the preceding four chapters so as to make a transition to Chapter V which presents an illustrative case of a structured analysis by Parsons.)"(p.120), then apparently inserted "preliminary draft February 8?, 1963 Parsons' Solution to the Problem of Social Order as a Method for Making Everyday Activities Observable 'From the Actor's Point of View'" (ending at p.179). So, p.1 - 3, p. 123 - p. 179 Preliminary Draft February 8, 1963 Parsons Solution to the Problem of Social Order as a Method for Making Everyday Activities Observable "From the Actor's Point of View" is inserted.
p.1 - p.47 Chapter ECONOMY, POLITY, MONEY, AND POWER
p.1 - p.29 Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT OF MATERIALS ON 1940 ARTICLE ON STRATIFICATION - AD HOC PARSONS
p.1 - p.41 Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT FOR ILLUSTRATIVE USE OF "STRUCTURED STRAIN"
p.1 - p.128 Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT AND NOTE FOR A CHAPTER ON VALUES
Additional Information:
(1) The change of schedule will be announced on this page.
(2) The class schedule may be changed considering the seminar participants' needs to present their own research to the class or by other contingencies; then the classes will move down accordingly.
(3) The Paper on "Parsons' Solution" was read in our 2014 seminar, so we will skip this part.
(4) On-line internet participation to the seminar will be possible via Skype or FaceTime depending on the Kobe University's network (KHAN)'s capacity. Please let me know about the expected on-line participation in advance for necessary arrangements.
(5) The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my sites: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology, and Ethnomethodology after 1970 - Suggestions and Informations to be added to these sites are welcomed.
(6) Changes and additions in this site will be announced on twitter and Facebook.
Materials:
-> 2016-17 Fall-WInter Seminar Materials (Password Required)
Additional Information:
MAP -> LINK to Kobe University Access Map (The "frontier" building is the building, No 29.)
While this is a credited course for the graduate students of legal sociology of Kobe University, anyone who is interested is welcome to attend (without credits).
2016
EMCA Seminar: Fall-Winter of 2016-17
13:30-15:30,Tuesdays, October 18, 2016 - April 18, 2017
Room 304, 3rd Floor, "the Frontier" Building,
Rokkodai-Campus, Kobe University
Shiro Kashimura
Professor, School of Law
Kobe University
Theme: Harold Garfinkel's Projects in early 1960's
The EMCA Seminar in Fall/Winter of 2016 focuses on Harold Garfinkel's unpublished seminar transcripts and conference papers in early 1960's. The materials include: Parsons' Primer (1960-63), Transcriptions of Ethnomethodology Seminar of September and October of 1962, Talks on "reasonable accounts" delivered by HG, Harvey Sacks, Egon Bittner & Edward Rose at the 16th World Affairs Conference, University of Colorado, 1963.
Texts of Garfinkel's Seminar of September 25, October 2 (part), and October 9, with some comments -> LINK
Part I. Garfinkel's Ethnomethodology Seminar of 1962
[1][2] October 18, 25
September 25, 1962
[3] [4] November 1, 8
October 2, 1962
[5][6] November 15, 22
October 9, 1962 File 1
[7] [8] November 29, December 6
October 9, 1962 File 2
[9] [10] December 13, 20
October 9, 1962 File 3
Texts of Garfinkel's Seminar of September 25, October 2 (part), and October 9, with some comments -> LINK
Garfinkel & Sacks 1967 On "Setting" in Conversation
Part II. Garfinkel (1960-63) PARSONS PRIMER - "AD HOC" USES (Draft - June 1960)
[11] January 10, 2017
p.1 - p.9 Chapter I
[12] January 17, 2017
p.10 - p.44 Chapter II INTRODUCTORY COMMENTS TO THE PROBLEM OF SOCIAL ORDER
[13] January 24
p.45 - p.78 Chapter III THE PROBLEM OF SOCIAL ORDER
[14] January 31
p.79 - p.120 Chapter IV "ADEQUATE' DESCRIPTIONS OF SOCIAL STRUCTURES
[NOTE: Garfinkel wrote at the end of Chapter IV "(Insert at this point a summary of the preceding four chapters so as to make a transition to Chapter V which presents an illustrative case of a structured analysis by Parsons.)"(p.120), then apparently inserted "preliminary draft February 8?, 1963 Parsons' Solution to the Problem of Social Order as a Method for Making Everyday Activities Observable 'From the Actor's Point of View'" (ending at p.179). So, p.1 - 3, p. 123 - p. 179 Preliminary Draft February 8, 1963 Parsons Solution to the Problem of Social Order as a Method for Making Everyday Activities Observable "From the Actor's Point of View" is inserted.
[15] February 7
p.1 - p.47 Chapter ECONOMY, POLITY, MONEY, AND POWER
[16] February 14
p.1 - p.29 Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT OF MATERIALS ON 1940 ARTICLE ON STRATIFICATION - AD HOC PARSONS
[17] February 21
p.1 - p.41 Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT FOR ILLUSTRATIVE USE OF "STRUCTURED STRAIN"
[18] [19] February 28, March 7
p.1 - p.128 Chapter PARTIAL DRAFT AND NOTE FOR A CHAPTER ON VALUES
Part III. Roundtable on "Reasonable Accounts": transcripts of the talks delivered at Sixteenth Annual Conference on World Affairs, University of Colorado, April 11 and 12, 1963.
[20] March 14
Harold Garfinkel "Mocking Up the Rules of Everyday Activities"
[21] March 21
Harvey Sacks "More on Mock-Ups"
[22] April 4
Egon Bittner "Ethical Symbols"
[23] April 11
Harold Garfinkel "Reasonable Accounts"
[24] April 18
Edward Rose, Harvey Sacks, Egon Bittner, and Harold Garfinkel "Translations"
Additional Information:
(1) The change of schedule will be announced on this page.
(2) The class schedule may be changed considering the seminar participants' needs to present their own research to the class or by other contingencies; then the classes will move down accordingly.
(3) The Paper on "Parsons' Solution" was read in 2014 seminar, so we will skip this part.
(4) On-line internet participation to the seminar will be possible via Skype or FaceTime depending on the Kobe University's network (KHAN)'s capacity. Please let me know about the expected on-line participation in advance for necessary arrangements.
(5) The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my sites: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology, and Ethnomethodology after 1970 - Suggestions and Informations to be added to these sites are welcomed.
(6) Changes and additions in this site will be announced on twitter and Facebook.
Materials:
-> 2016-17 Fall-WInter Seminar Materials (Password Required)
Additional Information:
MAP -> LINK to Kobe University Access Map (The "frontier" building is the building, No 29.)
While this is a credited course for the graduate students of legal sociology of Kobe University, anyone who is interested is welcome to attend (without credits).
2016
EMCA Seminar: Spring-Summer Quarters of 2016
13:30-16:30,Tuesdays, April 19 - July 26, 2016
Room 303, 3rd Floor, "Frontier" Building,
Rokkodai-Campus, Kobe University
Shiro Kashimura
Professor, School of Law
Kobe University
Theme: Harold Garfinkel's Projects: 1970-1990
The EMCA Seminar in Spring and Summer quarters of 2016 focuses on Harold Garfinkel's unpublished projects during the years of 1970s to 80s. Principally drawing on the unpublished drafts written by HG and his collaborators in the period, we shall examine and try to advance a deeper understanding of distinctive themes, methods, and reasonings of EM.
April 19 [1] Introduction
樫村「社会的世界の把握はいかにして可能か—エスノメソドロジーの失われた原問題をめぐって」(2016年3月23日、北海道大学法理論研究会報告」-> LINK (本文、図)
April 26 [2] Studies of Work
(Reading material to be provided for participants only)
May 10, 17, 24 [3] EM's Issues and Ways of Working
Harold Garfinkel "Sources of Issues and Ways of Working: An Introduction to the Study of Naturally Organized Ordinary Activities."
May 31, June 7, 14 [4] Natural Sciences
Harold Garfinkel, Eric Livingston, Michael Lynch, Douglas MacBeth, & Albert B. Robillard "Respecifying the Natural Sciences as Discovering Sciences of Practical Action, I & II: Doing So Ethnographically by Administering a Schedule of Contingencies in Discussions with Laboratory Scientists and by Hanging Around Their Laboratories (Selected Materials **)
July 5, 12, 19 [5] "Inter-sexed"l Persons and Their "Passing"
Norbert Wiley with Harold Garfinkel (March 31, 1980) "Discussion: (1) The Case of Agnes, (2) Why Do Ethnomethodologists Prefer to Talk about 'Production' Instead of 'Reality Construction."
July 26, August 2, 9 [6] Kids' Culture
Harold Garfinkel, George Girton, Eric Livingston, & Harvey Sacks, "Studies of Kids' Culture and Kids' Talk" (a project report) (1982?)
-> Course Materials (Password Required)
Additional Information:
The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my site: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology.
MAP -> LINK to Kobe University Access Map (The "frontier" building is the building, No 29.)
While this is a credited course for the graduate students of legal sociology of Kobe University, anyone who is interested is welcome to attend (without credits).
2015
テーマ:ガイダンス、言語、生活世界 Guidance, Language, and the Life-World
イントロダクションでは、アカウント、秩序などのEMCAのテーマのほか、1920年ごろのアメリカのハーレム・ルネサンスに関して議論します。第1部では、ズナニエツキの著作を素材にガイダンス行為について議論します。第2部では、ケネス・バークの著作を素材にEMCAが言語をどう捉えるかについて議論します。第3部では、人工的文化的な意味の世界としての生活世界の構造について、シュッツ、ギュルヴィッチ、ガーフィンケルの捉え方を検討します。
時間:毎週火曜日13:30-16:30 (最大限)
場所:神戸大学六甲台キャンパス第2学舎102号室
Scheduler:
Introduction to the Themes of the Seminar:
October 6 [1] 樫村「アカウントの社会学的解釈」(Kashimura (2015 forthcoming)
"Sociological Interpretation of Accounts") -> LINK
October 13 [2] 樫村「法社会学の対象と理論」(Kashimura (2015 forthcoming) "The
Objects and Theories of Sociology of Law") -> LINK
October 20 [3] Paul V. Murphy (2012) "Mulatto America," chapter 4 of
his The New Era: American Thought and Culture in the 1920s. (Rowman &
Littlefield Publishers Inc.): 109-147.
Part I: Guidance as a Type of Social Actions
October 27 [4] Florian Znaniecki (1936) "Educational Guidance,"
chapter VII of his Social Actions.(Farrar and Rinehart): 189-230.
November 3 (no class)
November 10 [5] Florian Znaniecki (1998) "Education for Democracy," a
chapter in his Education and Social Change (Frankfurt am Main, Peter
Lang GmbH): 41-121.
Part II: The Pragmatic Uses of Language
November 17,24[6] & [7] Kenneth Burke (1937) "Acceptance and
Rejection," the Part I of Attitudes Toward History. (University of
California Press): 3-107.
December 1 (no class)
December 8 [8] Kenneth Burke (1966) "Poetics in Particular, Language
in General (1961)," in his Language as Symbolic Action: Essays on
Life, Literature and Method.(University of California Press): 25-43.
Part III: The Life-World as Group's Practices and Objects
December 15, 22 [9] & [10] Alfred Schutz & Thomas Luckmann (1983) "The
Life-World as the Province of Practice," chapter 5 of The Structures
of the Life-World, Volume II. (Northwestern University Press.): 1-97.
January 5 [11] Aron Gurwitsch "The Perceptual Process'" in The
Collected Works of Aron Gurwitsch (1901-1973). Volume III: The Field
of Consciousness: Theme, Thematic Field, and Margin. Springer:
195-219.
January 12 [12] Harold Garfinkel (1949) "Style, Tactics, and
Strategies of Communication," "Group," & "Specific Problems," in his
Seeing Sociologically: Routine Grounds of Social Action. (Paradigm
Publishers): 182-216..
January 19 [13] Harold Garfinkel (1952) "Theory of the Object," in his
Perception of the Other: A Study in Social Order.
(Ph.D.Thesis):284-315.
2015
EMCA Seminar
Spring-Summer of 2015
Shiro Kashimura
Professor, School of Law
Kobe University
Theme: Life-Worlds, Immigration and Cultural Reflection
The Spring-Summer term of 2015 EMCA Seminar considers such complex interactional phenomena as deviant career, ethnicity, immigration and cultural confrontation. On the way, we will examine them as the phenomena of the Life-World. The seminar will start with considering the concept of "definition of situation" then "career of individual" through the subjective sociology of William I. Thomas. Then we examine the phenomena of immigration, national culture, and universalistic individualism of modern society through the works by Morawska, Znaniecki, and Parsons. We shall examine the complexity of Life-World phenomena of Drama through the early work of Schutz, and the concepts of bodily reflection as Marginal Consciousness through the work of Gurwitsch. After examining the two stages of Schutz's life to place his theory in German and American intellectual contexts, we try to learn the relationship of the life-world knowledge and the society at large.
Materials for the Seminar: (教材の順番を変更しました。2015.6.2)
[1] 相互反映性の原則の学説史的起源 -> LINK
[2] Chapter 1 "The Wishes" and Chapter 2 "The Regulation of the Wishes" of The Unadjusted Girl: With Cases and Standpoint for Behavioral Analysis (1923) by William I. Thomas, Little Brown & Company: 1 - 69. (The book is available online.)
[3] Chapter 1 of Ewa Morawska For Bread with Butter:The Life-Worlds of East Central Europeans in Johnstown, Pennsylvania, 1890-1940 (Interdisciplinary Perspectives on Modern History) 1986.
[4] Chapter 1 of Florian Znaniecki Modern Nationalities 1973.
[5] Talcott Parsons "Individuality and Institutionalized Individualism." Chapter 10 of American Society: A Theory of the Societal Community (edited by Giuseppe Sciortino), Paradigm Publishers, 2007.
[6] Alfred Schutz "Meaning Structure of Drama and Opera" in Life Forms and Meaning Structure. Translated by Helmut R. Wagner. Rutledge, 1982: 180-207.
[7] Michael D. Barber, "Social Science and Philosophy (1919-38): Weber and Bergson" Chapter 2 of The Participating Citizen: A Biography of Alfred Schutz. SUNY Press. 2004: 25-39
[8] Michael D. Barber "The Years 1952 to 1956: Philosophical Midwifery; Correspondence and Research" of The Participating Citizen: A Biography of Alfred Schutz. SUNY Press. 2004: 167-80.
[9] Alfred Schutz & Thomas Luckmann "Knowledge and Society" in The Structures of the Life-World. Northwestern University Press, 1973: 243-331.
[10] Aron Gurwitsch "Marginal Consciousness" in The Collected Works of Aron Gurwitsch (1901-1973). Volume III: The Field of Consciousness, Springer.: 451-537.
[11] Aron Gurwitsch "Outline of a Theory of 'Essentially Occasioned Expressions'" in The Collected Works of Aron Gurwitsch (1901-1973). Volume III: The Field of Consciousness, Springer: 451-537.
-> Course Materials (Password Required)
Additional Information:
The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my site: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology.
Time & Place:
The class will meet in Room 302 of Frontier Building at 13:30-16:30 (the ending time depending on the discussion) on every Tuesday starting on April 14, 2015.
Whereas this is a credited course for the graduate students of legal sociology of Kobe University, anyone who is interested is welcome to attend (without credits).
2014
EMCA Seminar Fall-Winter 2014:
Knowledge, Consciousness, and Action
Professor Shiro Kashimura
Graduate School of Law
Kobe University
Purpose
The Fall-Winter term of 2014 EMCA Seminar will examine the basic building blocks of the idea of Ethnomethodology: Knowledge, Consciousness, and Action. Its first part considering the materials by Helmer & Rescher, and by Mannheim introduces the concepts of "accounting" and "documentary method of interpretation" among the Garfinkel's idea of ethnomethodology. The question of the connectedness of accounting and knowledge will be pursued by reading 2 addtitonal materials focusing on the working concept of "information," Garfinkel's 1952 manuscript (published in 2006) and J.S.Bruner's paper. The second part of the seminar tries to clarify the question of how knowledge reflectively connect themselves within the system of practical-action. The first 2 materials by Hinkle and by Hawthorn inform us of the background of Americal sociology at the time. The materials by Znaniecki, Schütz, Gurwitsch, and Burke are the group of manifestations of European-American thought as to the concept of practical actions that were important not only for Garfinkel but also for the development of American sociology, much of which is forgotten by the current sociaological thoughts. We conclude with a "conceptual" analysis of Parsons' theory by a Dutch sociologist and his former student, Hans Adriaansens.
Materials for the Seminar:
On the Epistemology of the Inexact Sciences (1958) by Olaf Helmer and Nicholas Rescher, Rand Corporation. (The booklet is available online.)
"On the Interpretation of Weltanschauung" (1952)[=1921-22] by Karl Mannheim Essays on the Sociology of Knowledge, Tr. and ed. by Paul Kecskemeti (New York:Oxford U.P.): 33-83. (The chapter is available online.)
Toward a Sociological Theory of Information (1952) by Harold Garfinkel: pp. 110-159.
"Going Beyond the Information Given"(1957) by Jerome S. Bruner in his Beyond the Information Given, selected & edited by Jeremy M. Anglin, London, George Allen & Unwin: pp. 218-238.
"Possible European Influence on American Theory," (1994) a chapter by Roscoe C. Hinkle, in his Developments in American Sociological Theory, 1915-1950, SUNY Press: pp. 273-300.
"History Ignored" & "History Unresolved," chapters by G. Hawthorn (1987) , in his Enlightment and Despair: A History of Social Theory,Cambridge University Press: pp. 191-253.
"Cooperative Guidance" & "Primary Opposition," (1936) chapters by Florian Znaniecki , in his Social Actions, pp. 162-179, 312-344.
The Social Role of the Man of Knowledge (1940) by Florian Znaniecki .
"Reflections on the Problem of Relevance," (1945) by Alfred Schuetz in his Collected Papers V. Phenomenology and the Social Sciences, edited by Lester Embree, Springer: pp. 93-199
"Some Principles of Gestalt Psychology," (1953=1962) by A. Gurwitsch , in his The Collected Works of Aron Gurwitsch (1901-1973) Volume III, edited by Richard Zaner, Springer: pp. 86-148.
"Scope and Reduction," by Kenneth Burke (1945), A Grammar of Motives: pp. 58-125 (The book is available online reading.)
"The New Voluntaristic Action Theory," & "Testing The Theory Against Its Premises," (1980) chapters by H.P.M. Adriaansens in his Talcott Parsons and the Conceptual Dilemma, Routledge & Kegan Paul: pp. 116-175.
Additional Information:
The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my site: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology.
Time & Place:
The class will meet in Room 102 of Law Building at 13:30-15:50 (the ending time depending on the discussion) on every Tuesday starting on October 11, 2014.
Whereas this is a credited course for the graduate students of legal sociology of Kobe University, anyone who is interested is welcome to attend (without credits).
2014
EMCA Seminar 2014 : Garfinkel's Early Works
Professor Shiro Kashimura
Graduate School of Law
Kobe University
In the Spring-Summer term of 2014 we would like to examine the papers written by Harold Garfinkel in the years prior to the seminal publication of Studies in Ethnomethodology (1967). The papers include "Inter- and Intra-racial Homicide" (1949), "Sociological Concepts and Methods for Psychiatrists"(1956), "Status Degradations" (1956), the selected chapters of The Perception of the Other: A Study in Social Order (1952) and Toward a Sociological Theory of Information (1952=2008), and some unpublished manuscripts. We shall look for the developments and influences up to the crystalization of the ideas of ethnomethodology around1954 and in the preceding and the following years. We shall conclude with considering the responses by sociologists in U.S. and elsewhere to the publication using the review articles and excerpts from The Purdue Symposium on Ethnomethodology in 1968.
The early publications and biographical events in Garfinkel's scholarly life are listed in my site: Formative Steps of Ethnomethodology.
The class will meet in Room 406 of “Frontier” Building at 10:40-14:50 (the ending time depending on the discussion) on every Tuesday starting on May 13, 2014.
2013
EMCA Seminar 2013-14 : On Symbolic Actions
Professor Shiro Kashimura
Graduate School of Law
Kobe University
In this term of 2013-2014 we would like to examine the organization and varieties of “symbolic actions” -- social actions which utilize the member's competency of using words heavily as its means, environments, and restraints. We begin by examining the theory of symbolic action by Kenneth Burke, then move on to 2 of the explication of Husserl’s theory of meaning and experience by Marvin Farber. Then we examine the phenomenological analysis of horizon by Helmut Kuhn and sociological analysis of invitation/enticement by Znaniecki. We will conclude by examining two analyses from contemporary EMCA -- the analysis of reading by Livingston followed by that of game-player’s rule-following by Liberman.
The class will meet in Room 405 of “Frontier” Building at 13:20-14:50 (or 10:40 am - 12:20 pm for some days) on every Thursday. There will be no class on October 17 due to my travelling, however. (Class hours information is corrected. 2013.10.3)
2013
The EMCA Seminar of 2013’s Summer considers the effects of phenomenology and sociology in the early 20th century of the US on Harold Garfinkel’s thought that eventually led to ethnomethodology by 1950s. Especially the seminar focuses on Florian Znaniecki’s move toward sociology and Husserl’s criticism of reason, as developed by Aron Gurwitsch & Alfred Schütz, with the aim of clarifying the operation of major intellectual forces of the time that moulded the epistemological tenet of ethnomethodology as a new way of studying society.
The seminar begins at Znaniecki’s sociological thought that presumably conveyed the European sociological/philosophical thinking to the US and its impacts on American sociology of the time. It is followed by the works in American development/transmission of phenomenology by such European/Exile thinkers as Schütz, Gurwitsch, Farber, and Kaufman from the early years up to the middle of 20th century. The seminar concludes with reading a chapter from Garfinkel’s Seeing Sociologically (1948) and a chapter from Liberman's recent book, Husserl's Criticism of Reason (2007).
The class meets on Tuesdays (10:40am - 12:10pm) according to the schedule that follows at Room 102 of the Law Faculty's Building II, Rokkodai, Kobe University. (The Building is no. 4 on this Map of Kobe University)
On chronological list of publications in the formative era (1934 - 1967) of ethnomethodology and phenomenology in America, visit the link.
For this course's reading materials visit here (restricted to students).
THE READING MATERIALS (updated, 2013/05/28)
2012
2012 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Seminar on Ethnomethodology and Conversation Analysis
(April-July 2011, Thursdays, 1:20 p.m. - 4:30 p.m.
Location: TBA )
Class Schedule and List of Readings
ReadingTwo Books on Understanding,Language
and Interacting Bodies
In this term of the seminar, we will read two books on understanding, language and interacting bodies, David Goode’s A World Without Words (1994), and Albert B. Robillard’s Meaning of Disability (2003), by reading one or two chapters a week alternately. We shall think about how human communications are done in practically possible and reliable ways through embedded presentation of words and bodies along with other contingent and ever-developing features of action-in-a-scene.
[ 1] (4.14)
Goode 1994:1-6
Translation Goode Foreword, Acknowledgments
Translation Goode Introduction
Robillard 2003: ix-xv
Translation Acknowledgments
[ 2] (4.21)
“Construction and Use of Data in Social Science Research”
Goode 1994:96-124 (Chapter 5)
Translation Goode Chapter 5
[ 3] (4.28)
"Can He Think?”, “The Trip”
Robillard 2003:145-184 (Chapters 8 & 9)
Translation Chapters 8
Translation Chapter 9 (未)
[ 4] (5.12)
“A World Without Words”
Goode 1994:7-46 (Chapter 2)
Translation Goode Chapter 2
[ 5] (5.19)
“You Are Lucky Your Wife Stuck With You”
Robillard 2003:35-47. (Chapter 2)
Translation Robillard Chapter 2
[ 6] (5.26)
“On Understanding Without Words”
Goode 1994:47-95 (Chapter 3)
Translation Goode Chapter 3 pp. 47-95
[ 7] (6.2)
“Communicating in Intensive Care”
Robillard 2003:48-63 (Chapter 3)
Translation Robillard Chapter 3
[ 8] (6.9)
“Kids, Culture, and Innocent”
Goode 1994:165-191. (Chapter 6)
Translation Goode Chapter 6
Mannoni, O. 1972 “Itard and His Savage”
[ 9] (6.16)
“Anger”, “Tragic Narratives”
Robillard 2003:64-81, 110-122 (Chapters 4 & 6)
Translation Robillard Chapter 4
Translation Robillard Chapter 6
[10] (6.23)
“Reflections 0n the Possibility of Understanding Without Formal Language”
Goode 1994:96-124 (Chapter 4)
Translation Goode Chapter 4
[11] (6.30)
“Isolation”
Robillard 2003: 82-109 (Chapter 5)
Translation Robillard Chapter 5
[12] (7.7)
“Conclusions”, “Appendix”
Goode 1994: 192-216
Translation Goode Conclusion
Translation Goode Appendix
[13] (7.14)
”Bionic Man”
Robillard 2003: 82-109 (Chapter 7)
Translation Robillard Chapter 7
Source:
David Goode (1994) A World Without Words: The Social Construction of Children Born Deaf and Blind (Temple University Press)
Albert B. Robillard (2003) Meaning of Disability: The Lived Experience of Paralysis (Temple University Press)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2011
Morality of Rules and Laws
今学期の趣旨について
I. Visibility of Morality
[ 1] (10.7)
Harold Garfinkel
"Role and the Concept of the Finite Province of Meaning"
in Harold Garfinkel, Seeing Sociologically 2006: 107-132.
1 Garfinkel.pdf
抄訳
Major Events in H.G.’s Early Years
[ 2] (10.14)
David Sudnow
"Normal Crimes: Sociological Features of the Penal Code in a Public Defender Office"
in Social Problems, Vol. 12, No. 3 (Winter, 1965), pp. 255-276
2 Sudnow.pdf
抄訳
[ 3] (10.21)
Harvey Sacks
"Notes on Police Assessment of Moral Character"
in David Sudnow, ed. Studies in Social Interaction (1972): 280-293
3 Sacks.pdf
翻訳 [岡田光弘さんの訳です]
第2版 [岡田さんの訳にもとづき、樫村が気づいたところの改訂を試みました]
[ 4] (10.28)
John Heritage
"Conversation Analysis and Institutional Talk"
in Kristine L. Fitch & Robert E. Sanders, eds. Handbook of Language and Social Interaction 2005: 103-147.
4 Heritage.pdf
抄訳
II. Morality of Social Roles
[ 5] (11.4)
Jim Schenkein
"Identity Negotiations in Conversation"
in Jim Schenkein, ed. Studies in the Organization of Conversational Interaction 1978: 57-78.
5 Schenkein.pdf
抄訳
[ 6] (11.11)
D. R. Watson
"Some Features of the Elicitation of Confessions in Murder Interrogations"
in George Psathas, ed. Interaction Competence 1990: 263-295
6 Watson.pdf
抄訳
[ 7] (11.18)
Martha Komter
"Remorse, Redress, and Reform: Blame-Taking in the Courtroom"
in Max Travers & John F. Manzo, eds. Law in Action: Ethnomethodological and Conversation Analytic Approaches to Law 1997: 239-97.
7 Komter.pdf
抄訳
[ 8] (11.25)
J. Maxwell Atkinson & Paul Drew
"The Production of Justifications and Excuses by Witnesses in Cross-Examination"
in J. Maxwell Atkinson & Paul Drew Order in Court: The Organisation of Verbal Interaction in Judicial Settings. 1979: 136-187
8 Atkinson & Drew.pdf
参考: 「血の日曜日」事件について -> THE BLOODY SUNDAY TRIBUNAL OF INQUIRY
抄訳
[ 9] (12.2)
Anita Pomerantz & Jenny Mandelbaum
"Conversation Analytic Approaches to the Relevance and Uses of Relationship Categories in Interaction"
in Kristine L. Fitch & Robert E. Sanders, eds. Handbook of Language and Social Interaction 2005: 149-171
9 Pomerantz & Mandelbaum.pdf
抄訳
III. Telling Stories as Moral Act
[ 10] (12.9)
Michael Moerman
"The Use of Precedent in Natural Conversation: A Study in Practical Legal Reasoning" (1973)
in Michael Lynch & Wes Sharrock, eds. Harold Garfinkel 2003 Vol.3: 371-393.
10 Moerman.pdf
抄訳
[ 11] (12.16)
D. R. Watson
"Interdisciplinary Considerations in the Analysis of Pro-Terms"
in Graham Button & John R. E. Lee, eds. Talk and Social Organisation 1987: 261-289
11 Watson.pdf
抄訳
[ 12] (1.13)
Anita Pomerantz
"Descriptions in Legal Settings"
in Graham Button & John R. E. Lee, eds. Talk and Social Organisation 1987: 226-243
12 Pomerantz.pdf
抄訳
[13] (1.20)
Harvey Sacks
"Some Technical Considerations of a Dirty Joke"
in Jim Schenkein, ed. Studies in the Organizatoin of Conversational Interaction. 1978 : 249-269.
13 Sacks.pdf
抄訳
[14] (1.27)
Wes Sharrock & Roy Turner
"On a Conversational Environment of Equivocality"
in Jim Schenkein, ed. Studies in the Organizatoin of Conversational Interaction. 1978 : 173-197.
14 Sharrock & Turner.pdf
抄訳
2011
Seminar on Ethnomethodology and Conversation Analysis
(April-July 2011, Thursdays, 1:20 p.m. - 4:30 p.m.
Location: TBA )
Class Schedule and List of Readings
ReadingTwo Books on Understanding,Language
and Interacting Bodies
In this term of the seminar, we will read two books on understanding, language and interacting bodies, David Goode’s A World Without Words (1994), and Albert B. Robillard’s Meaning of Disability (2003), by reading one or two chapters a week alternately. We shall think about how human communications are done in practically possible and reliable ways through embedded presentation of words and bodies along with other contingent and ever-developing features of action-in-a-scene.
[ 1] (4.14)
Goode 1994:1-6
Translation Goode Foreword, Acknowledgments
Translation Goode Introduction
Robillard 2003: ix-xv
Translation Acknowledgments
[ 2] (4.21)
“Construction and Use of Data in Social Science Research”
Goode 1994:96-124 (Chapter 5)
Translation Goode Chapter 5
[ 3] (4.28)
"Can He Think?”, “The Trip”
Robillard 2003:145-184 (Chapters 8 & 9)
Translation Chapters 8
Translation Chapter 9 (未)
[ 4] (5.12)
“A World Without Words”
Goode 1994:7-46 (Chapter 2)
Translation Goode Chapter 2
[ 5] (5.19)
“You Are Lucky Your Wife Stuck With You”
Robillard 2003:35-47. (Chapter 2)
Translation Robillard Chapter 2
[ 6] (5.26)
“On Understanding Without Words”
Goode 1994:47-95 (Chapter 3)
Translation Goode Chapter 3 pp. 47-95
[ 7] (6.2)
“Communicating in Intensive Care”
Robillard 2003:48-63 (Chapter 3)
Translation Robillard Chapter 3
[ 8] (6.9)
“Kids, Culture, and Innocent”
Goode 1994:165-191. (Chapter 6)
Translation Goode Chapter 6
Mannoni, O. 1972 “Itard and His Savage”
[ 9] (6.16)
“Anger”, “Tragic Narratives”
Robillard 2003:64-81, 110-122 (Chapters 4 & 6)
Translation Robillard Chapter 4
Translation Robillard Chapter 6
[10] (6.23)
“Reflections 0n the Possibility of Understanding Without Formal Language”
Goode 1994:96-124 (Chapter 4)
Translation Goode Chapter 4
[11] (6.30)
“Isolation”
Robillard 2003: 82-109 (Chapter 5)
Translation Robillard Chapter 5
[12] (7.7)
“Conclusions”, “Appendix”
Goode 1994: 192-216
Translation Goode Conclusion
Translation Goode Appendix
[13] (7.14)
”Bionic Man”
Robillard 2003: 82-109 (Chapter 7)
Translation Robillard Chapter 7
Source:
David Goode (1994) A World Without Words: The Social Construction of Children Born Deaf and Blind (Temple University Press)
Albert B. Robillard (2003) Meaning of Disability: The Lived Experience of Paralysis (Temple University Press)
2009
Theme: Rule, Reason and Reality
I. Rules, Action and Reality
[ 1] Accounting by Rule
D.L. Wieder
"Rules as Explanation of Action"
in Wieder (1974) 29-45
Wieder_Ch1.pdf Wieder_Bibliography.pdf 訳 コメント
[ 2] Rule and Activity
D.L.Wieder
"Persuasion and Reflexive Formulation"
in Wieder (1974) 167-182
Wieder_Ch6.pdf 訳 コメント
[ 3] Perception through Accounting by Rule
D.L.Wieder
"'Telling the Code' as a Guide to Perception: The Inner Structure of Social Reality"
in Wieder (1974) 183-214
Wieder_Ch7.pdf 訳 コメント
[ 4] From Rule to Society
D.L.Wieder "'Telling the Code' as an Exhibition of Order"
in Wieder (1974) 215-224
Wieder Ch8.pdf 訳 コメント
D.H.Zimmerman "Preface"
in Wieder (1974) 9-26
Wieder_Preface.pdf 訳 コメント
II. Reason-in-Action
[ 5] What Is Ethnomethodology?
H.Garfinkel
"Author's Introduction"
Introduction.pdf 訳 コメント
"Author's Acknowledgements as an Autobiographical Account"
Acknowledgement.pdf 訳 コメント
"The Central Claims of Ethnomethodology"
CentralClaims.pdf 訳 コメント
in Garfinkel (2002) 65-120
[ 6] Formal Theorizing on/as/in the Social Order
H.Garfinkel (with E.Bittner)
"Methodological Adequacy in the Quantitative Study of Selection Criteria and Selection Activities in Psychiatric Outpatient Clinics"
in Garfinkel (1967)
Garfinkel & Bittner 1967.pdf Garfinkel with Bittner 1967.txt 訳 コメント
[ 7] Doing a Sociology
M.D.Baccus
"Sociological Indication and the Validity Criterion of Real World Social Theorizing"
in Garfinkel (ed.) (1986) 1-19
Baccus 1986.pdf テキスト版 訳 コメント
[ 8] Regulating
M.D.Baccus
"Multipiece Truck Wheel Accidents and Their Regulations"
in Garfinkel (ed.) (1986) 20-59
Baccus Regulation.pdf テキスト版 訳 コメント
参考資料 OSHAのすべて Multi-Piece Rim Accident Booklet
ホイール構造の図解(http://www.tyrelandweb.com/wheel/kouzou.html)
[ 9] Instruction Following
H.Garfinkel
"Instructions and Instructed Actions"
in Garfinkel (2002) 197-218
Instructions.pdf テキスト版 英文要約 コメント
[ 10] Teaching
H.Garfinkel
"A Study of the Work of Teaching Undergraduate Chemistry in Lecture Format"
in Garfinkel (2002) 219-244 Chapter7.pdf Chapter Seven.txt 抄訳 コメント
[ 11] Queueing
H.Garfinkel
"Autochthonous Order Properties of Formatted Queues"
in Garfinkel (2002) 245-261 Chapter8.pdf Chapter Eight.txt 抄訳 コメント
参考資料:7月4日のパレードの竹馬男 (http://www.sxc.hu/photo/135105)
[ 12] Doing a Scientific Demonstration
H.Garfinkel
"An Ethnomethodological Study of the Work of Calileo's Inclined Plane Demonstration of the Real Motion of Free Falling Bodies"
in Garfinkel (2002) 263-285 Chapter9.pdf Chapter Nine.txt 訳 コメント
Sources:
D.L.Wieder (1974) Language and Social Reality: The Case of Telling Convict Code. Mouton, The Hague.
H.Garfinkel (1967) Studies in Ethnomethodology. Prentice-Hall.
H.Garfinkel ed. (1986) Ethnomethodological Studies of Work. Routledge & Kegan Paul.
H.Garfinkel (2002) Ethnomethodology's Program. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
2009
Seminar on Ethnomethodology and Conversation Analysis (2009 April-July Fridays, 1:20 p.m.- #102)
Class Schedule and List of Readings (カッコ内は予定日)
I. What is Ethnomethodology
(4.17) M. Moerman & H. Sacks, On Understanding in the Analysis of Natural Conversation. 1971
教材-> Moerman&Sacks_1971.pdf 試訳 注釈
(4.24) M.Peyrot, Understanding Ethnomethodology: A Remedy for Some Common Misconceptions 1982
-> Peyrot 1982.pdf 抄訳 注釈
(5.1) 大学院生研究発表会のため休講
(5.8) 法社会学会(明治大学)のため休講
II. Norms and Categories in Competent Understanding of Society
(5.15) E.Bittner, The Concept of Organization. 1965
-> Bittner 1965.pdf 試訳 注釈
(5.29) E.Bittner, The Police on Skid-Row: A Study of Peace Keeping. 1967
-> Bittner 1967.pdf 要約 抄訳 注釈
(6.5) 大学院生研究発表会のため休講
(6.12) E.Bittner, Objectivity and Realism in Sociology. 1973
-> Bittner 1973.pdf 試訳 注釈
(6.19) P. Drew. Accusations: The Occasioned Use of Member's Knowledge of 'Religious Geography' in Describing Events. 1978
-> Drew 1978.pdf 英文要約 試訳 注釈
(6.26) D.A.Goode, On Understanding Without Words: Communication Between a Deaf-Blind Child and her Parents. 1990
-> Goode_1990.pdf 英文要約 試訳 注釈
III. Variety of Organized Perceptions
(7.3) John O'Neil, From Phenomenology to Ethnomethodology: Some Radical 'Misreadings' 1980
-> Oneil 1980.pdf 試訳 注釈
(7.24) R.J.Anderson, J.A.Hughes & W.W.Sharrock, The Relationship Between Ethnomethodology and Phenomenology. 1985
-> Anderson Hughes Sharrock 1985.pdf 試訳 注釈
(7.31) A.V.Cicourel, Interviews, Surveys, and the Problem of Ecological Validity. 1982
-> Cicourel 1982.pdf 試訳 注釈
(8.7) L. Suchman and Brigitte Jordan, Interactional Troubles in Face-to-face Survey Interviews. 1990
-> Suchman Jordan 1990.pdf 試訳 注釈
(9.3) J. Coulter & E.D.Parsons, The Praxiology of Perception: Visual Orientations and Practical Action. 1991
-> Coulter Parsons 1991.pdf 試訳 注釈
2008
2008.10.9
D.L.Wieder 1988 From Resource to Topic: Some Aims of Conversation Analysis (part) 268-275
Wieder1988.pdf
2008.10.16
D.H.Zimmerman & D.L.Wieder 1971 Ethnomethodology and the Problem of Order (part)
Zimmerman&Wieder1971.pdf Zimmerman&Wieder1971要約.pdf
2008.10.23
H.Sacks 1963 Sociological Description (part) 204-209
Sacks1963.pdf Sacks1963_試訳.pdf
2008.10.30
A.W.Rawls 1999 Harold Garfinkel (part) 18-26
Rawls1999.pdf Rawls_1999_J.pdf
2008.11.13
D.H.Zimmerman & M.Pollner Everyday World as a Phenomenon (part) 206-215
Zimmerman&Pollner1971.pdf Z&P_Notes.pdf Zimmerman&Pollner_J.pdf
2008.11.20
H. Garfinkel 1964 Studies of the Routine Grounds of Everyday Life (part)
Garfinkel1964.pdf Garfinkel_1964_J.pdf
2008.11.27
G. Psathas 1979 Organizational Features of Direction Maps
Psathas1979.pdf tPsathas_1979_J.pdf
2008.12.04
R. Hilbert 1992 The Status of Rules in Normal Life (Chapter 2 of Classical Roots of Ethnomethodology)
Hilbert1992.pdf Hilbert_1992_j.pdf
2008.12.18
山崎晶子・菅靖子 2004 博物館研究
Yamazaki_2004.pdf
江原由美子 1985 服装の社会学
江原1985.pdf